The Court of Appeal has ruled that the construction of the standard gauge railway (SGR) failed to comply with the law.
In a judgment Friday, the judges of the Court of Appeal faulted Kenya Railways Corporation, saying as the procuring entity, it failed to comply with, and violated provisions of Article 227 (1) of the Constitution and Sections 6 (1) and 29, of the Public Procurement and Disposal Act, 2005 in the procurement of the SGR project.
Justices Martha Koome, Gatembu Kairu and Jamila Mohamed said it was not accurate, as was claimed KR that the engagement of China Road and Bridge Corporation (CRBC) as the contractor was as a result of dictation by the financing agreement.
“We conclude, therefore, that the engagement of CRBC was not an obligation arising from “negotiated grant or loan” agreement for purposes of Section 6 of the Act,” the judges said.
They added that the engagement of CRBC was not an obligation arising from “negotiated grant or loan” agreement for purposes of Section 6 of the Act.
READ ALSO
SGR as a vital enabler of multi-billion county economic corridor
Politics of SGR and how leaders failed the people
SGR millionaires blow compensation cash in Taita Taveta
Tanzania joins Kenya, Uganda in fall back to old railway
Mr Okiya Omtatah together with Law Society of Kenya (LSK) had challenged the project arguing that it was single-sourced yet it is financed by Kenyans.
The activist argued that the project was “a 100 percent Kenyan funded venture” and therefore subject to the standards and procedures laid out for the procurement of goods and services by public entities in the Constitution and the statutes.
He said KR violated the provisions of the Constitution because it was not subjected to open tender by inviting bids for the supply of the goods and services as required under Article 227 of the Constitution.
LSK and Mr Omtatah further said there was no due diligence, there was no independent feasibility study and design of the project and there was a conflict of interest in the Government contracting CRBC to implement the project whose feasibility study and design it had intriguingly carried out for free.
He also faulted the government for ‘christening’ the contract as a government to government contract.
But KR and CRBC defended the contract saying GoK entered into a financing agreement with Exim Bank of China for a concessional and commercial loan to support the project.
In a judgement in 2014, Justice Isaac Lenaola, the High Court judge, dismissed the petitions and allowed the construction to continue unhindered. The Activist and LSK moved to the Court of Appeal to challenge the decision.
In the judgement Friday, the judges dismissed claims by Mr Omtatah that Parliament was by-passed and that environmental considerations were not considered have no merit.
more recommended stories
TAITA TAVETA: SEVEN DAYS HAVE ELAPSED — HAS SENATOR KAJWANG SENT WAKUJAA’S GOVERNMENT FILES TO EACC?By Kwaela News Network (KNN).
MZIMA II WATER PROJECT: KSh 50.6 BILLION COASTAL PIPELINE MOVES CLOSER TO IMPLEMENTATIONChinese firm identified as proposed developer.
Nairobi in Darkness as Government Billing Dispute Leaves Residents Paying the PriceNAIROBI — As darkness descends on.
RUTO CONTRADICTS HIMSELF ON FOREIGNERS: FROM “VISA-FREE AFRICA” TO A CRACKDOWN ON SMALL TRADERSPresident William Ruto’s latest crackdown.
NEW UNIFORMS, SAME OLD PROBLEMS: YOU CAN’T TAILOR INTEGRITYPresident William Ruto has proudly unveiled.
SHARON’S JUSTICE CANNOT BE BOUGHTThe latest developments in the.
HOMA BAY VIOLENCE RAISES TROUBLING QUESTIONS ABOUT KENYA’S DEMOCRACYThe shocking violence that engulfed the.
JUSTICE AT LAST: WHAT THE SHARON OTIENO MURDER CONVICTION MEANS FOR KENYAAfter nearly eight years of.
ALBERT OJWANG CASE: THE QUESTIONS KENYA REFUSES TO LET DIEThe death of Albert Ojwang in.
RELIEF FOOD SCANDAL RAISES SERIOUS QUESTIONS AS INVESTIGATIONS CONTINUEThe reported recovery of hundreds.
THE HALIMA NGACHE CASE: A COSTLY ASSAULT ON DIGITAL FREEDOM THAT DEMANDS ACCOUNTABILITYThe collapse of the case against.
WHY FIKIRINI JACOBS MUST STEP ASIDE AS THE CECIL OUMA PROBE CONTINUESThe tragic death of 28-year-old youth.
STOP THE KILLING, NOT MERELY COMPENSATE THE DEADAs Kenya approaches the second.
PRESIDENT RUTO’S FREQUENT FLYER PRESIDENCY: ARE KENYANS GETTING VALUE FOR MONEY?President William Ruto has returned to.
THE SINGAPORE ILLUSION: A REALITY CHECK ON THE STATE OF OUR NATIONThere is an increasingly persistent.
Could the Proposed Ebola Quarantine Facility Cost Kenya More Than It Gains?The proposed establishment of a United.

Leave a Comment