DEFLECTION IS NOT LEADERSHIP: MURKOMEN’S WORDS IN A TIME OF MOURNING

When Kipchumba Murkomen declared that police brutality “did not start three years ago… it started in 1963,” he may have intended to provide historical context. Instead, he exposed a troubling instinct: to look backward for excuses while the country bleeds in the present.

Yes, Kenya’s policing system has deep colonial roots dating back to independence in Kenya in 1963. That history is real. But invoking it now—amid fresh graves and grieving families—is not analysis. It is evasion.

Words That Carry Weight — and Consequences

During the Gen-Z protests that swept the country over economic hardship and governance concerns, Murkomen was widely reported as instructing police to shoot protesters who approached police stations. Even if later clarified, the damage was done. In a nation already tense from allegations of excessive force, such rhetoric does not calm the waters—it electrifies them.

The controversy intensified when President William Ruto publicly stated:

“They shouldn’t kill them but they should shoot their legs so they break and they can go to hospital on their way to court.”

That remark alone should have triggered immediate constitutional alarm. Kenyan law does not authorize police to maim suspects as punishment. Firearms are permitted only as a last resort to protect life. Anything beyond that crosses into illegality.

When leaders speak casually about shooting citizens—whether in the chest or in the leg—they erode the constitutional line between law enforcement and state violence.

The Law Is Clear

The High Court has previously barred unlawful use of live ammunition and excessive force during protests. Human-rights organizations such as Amnesty International and the Kenya National Commission on Human Rights have documented deaths, gunshot wounds, and allegations of extrajudicial conduct.

Against this backdrop, historical lectures about 1963 sound painfully detached.

If police brutality has existed since independence, as Murkomen argues, then that is not a defense of his tenure. It is an indictment of it. Leadership is measured not by how well one explains inherited problems, but by how decisively one confronts them.

Grief Is Not a Political Talking Point

Families who lost sons and daughters during the protests are not debating constitutional theory. They are burying children.

To them, the “1963” remark feels less like historical reflection and more like abdication. It suggests a government more comfortable distributing blame across six decades than accepting responsibility for today.

No administration inherits a perfect system. But every administration owns its response.

A Test of Accountability

If Murkomen believes police brutality predates him, then he should be leading the charge for:

  • Independent investigations into protest deaths
  • Transparent publication of findings
  • Swift prosecution of officers who violated the law
  • Clear, unambiguous directives prohibiting unlawful force

Anything less confirms the critics’ charge: that history is being used as a shield.

Kenya does not need rhetorical toughness. It needs moral clarity.

When state officials normalize the language of shooting citizens, even conditionally, they risk normalizing the act itself. And when they invoke 1963 to explain 2024 and 2025, they forget a fundamental truth:

History explains a problem.

It does not excuse its continuation.

If police brutality truly began at independence, then six decades later, the question is no longer when it started.

The question is:

Why, under your watch, does it continue?

more recommended stories