TAITA TAVETA COUNTY CECM’s VETTING – AN EXERCISE OF HITS AND MISSES?

By Jeremiah Kiwoi

‘’Vet’’ is a figurative contraction of veterinarian and was applied primarily in the 1860’s during horse -racing, primarily to treat ( read vet ) the horse before he races. The same has since morphed and is commonly used as a synonym for evaluate, especially in searching for flaws.

In the context of transitional justice, vetting is a formal process applied to identify and remove from office individuals responsible for abuses, especially from police, prison, army and judicial institutions.

Scholars argue that Vetting has been confused with Lustrating; That lustration is the systematic screening of candidates for public office and possible barring or removal from office BUT let us stick to what we are all familiar with , VETTING WITH INTENT TO APPROVE / DISAPPROVE FOR APPOINTMENT

In our setting, vetting is targeted at individuals who have been nominated by an appointing authority to serve in public office ; it is conducted within a set of rules, guidelines or criteria; and in every sense of the word, it is a rigorous process but which is equitable, legitimate, objective, safeguards human rights, and is governed by the rule of law and based on individual responsibility.

The Taita Taveta MCAs had four options before them – to conduct a comprehensive vetting process as part of a larger political compromise; to restrict themselves to the laid down criteria and exclude those who do not attain the suitability mark, this to be followed by a sober debate and a vote; to follow other persuasions including financial inducement, party preferences , overtures from the executive to approve the nominees ; or to simply exercise their ‘’raw power’’ by arm-twisting, chest- thumping and bullying the executive into submission under the guise of asserting the ‘’independence’’ of the house. Any which way, one of the four did apply.

What was the ideal for Taita Taveta County?

The vetting process was supposed to assure the citizens of Taita Taveta that the various dockets which form the Executive will be led by capable men and women who are equally competent, accomplished, trustworthy, and of unquestionable integrity and character.With the knowledge that vetting was not going to be a repeat exercise, we all expected that the nominees will be well prepared to respond to the questions and in so doing, have a chance to display their understanding of public service, experience, vision, capacity , ability , management skills. analytical skills , ability to analyse situations, problem solving and, more importantly, knowledge on their dockets and how they would use their positions to address the crucial issues affecting the lives of the people of Dawida and Tuweta.

Vetting is intended to be a means through which the current administration picks persons to address and remedy the drawbacks and setbacks that are at the heart of our county’s underdevelopment.

Approving people who are not qualified to positions critical to our development ambitions ought to be outrightly rejected.

The question we need to ask ourselves is whether the good governor in deciding his pick, took time alone (or with his inner circle) to vet his own nominees from a position of strength, knowledge, research and inquiry. He would have at the very onset weeded the undesirable persons out of his list, premised on the evidence of their unsuitability to hold public office. This would have saved him the agony of going back to the ‘’market place’’ once again. Generally, it was expected that MCAs would possibly not clear nominees whose suitability , competence and ability they doubt.

A Lesson for my good Governor- you opted to go for ‘’constituency balancing’’ or a ‘’reward system’’ to appease campaigners and vote rich areas but in so doing, you punished yourself by failing to identify qualified persons with the right education, integrity, proven track record, exceptional achievement and a sincere desire to bring and drive the much-needed transformation in the county. Sometimes good Sir, courage will mean that you make choices which also hurt you; you reject external pressure from political colleagues, associates and friends; and you tactfully resist any form of arm-twisting, blackmail and the urge to please everyone. Now that you have a chance to pick the second round of four nominees, heed to my advice. You fulfilled your part of the agreement(s). Move on. No more coercion and manipulation. You are no longer bound by anyone’s sense of entitlement. Nominate the four from any part of the county. This being politics, you already have a calculated way of explaining yourself out.

To the good Members of the County Assembly Appointments Committee , allegations will fly everywhere. While you may have stuck to your mandate, allow me to make my humble submissions.

Though you prepared yourselves to follow the set of guidelines in picking those who qualified to take up the crucial and challenging work as CECMs, the report which is now in the domain falls short of common expectations. You may possibly not hold a candle to the nominees whom you censured on the grounds that they either failed to articulate themselves well; had qualifications which were not in tandem with the dockets they were picked for; were aloof; were more experienced in teaching compared to technical know-how; or made sentiments construed to be against the spirit of devolution. This kind of reasoning cannot sustain any meaningful discourse when challenged. It was undeserving of you to profile the nominees as such persons. One would wonder whether they were being reprimanded. Instead you should have tested their willingness to make amends where they seemed to have fallen short of your anticipation.

According to County Government Act 35 (3)(4) , a person may be appointed as a member of the county executive committee if that person—(a) is a Kenyan citizen; (b) is a holder of at least a first degree from a university recognised in Kenya; (c) satisfies the requirements of Chapter Six of the Constitution; and (d) has knowledge, experience and a distinguished career of not less than five years in the field relevant to the portfolio of the department to which the person is being appointed. This should have formed the crux of your determination for suitability.

As MCAs and by law, your role is to studiously oversight the Executive.

While the fate of the four nominees has been sealed, remember that these are political appointments. Each of the ten county departments house competent technocrats whose responsibility is to aid and guide the CECMs in accomplishing the vision of their appointing authority. Did all the ten nominees meet the qualifications as provided for in the County Government Act 2012? If they did, you should not be the impediment – uphold the spirit and letter of the constitution which is equity and justice but subverting its intent. In exercising optimism, remember to temper it with caution in order to avoid disaster. You may have been very philosophical in your approach to determine who qualifies or not , but out there, it is the practicality that works. In any case you have the power to impeach CECMs when not satisfied with their performance.

Be that as it my, all is not lost. The future of TTC is still very bright. The assembly has a good mix of institutional memory, experience, freshness, zeal and ambition. It can only stifle its own growth if it misses on intent and purpose .The executive on the other hand has to be revolutionary. You must do things differently. You only have one game to play. Deliver Services. There is no more time to routinize, institutionalize, and normalize failure. After ten years of rhetoric , you are now dealing with a radically enlightened community, eager for change and not prepared for any short-changing. They have let some things pass quietly. In their silence , do not provoke a long and bitter backlash. The jig and dance are over. Get down to work.

more recommended stories