INVESTIGATIONS: FAULTY X-RAY MACHINE COMMISSIONED AT WESU SHOWS GAPS IN TTC HEALTH CARE

Governor Granton Samboja testing the X-Ray Machine at Wesu Hospital on 27th October 2021

By a Concerned Health Conscious Datuzen

Health is one of the most important pillars of our lives. When citizens vote for their leaders, they expect them to carry their best interest at heart health-wise. However, it is not all leaders that think this way, as some of them choose to gamble our health for the sake of filling their deep pockets. Unfortunately, Governor Granton Samboja did this when he commissioned an X-ray machine for Wesu Sub-County Hospital.

According to a professional survey done by the Radiation Protection Board from The Ministry of Health, the X-ray machine contravened several necessary precautions. The Radiation Control Inspectorate from the Coastal Region had to blatantly reject the X-ray that the governor intended for use at Wesu Subcounty Hospital. Below are some of the reasons the professional body gave for the dismissal.

Governor Samboja inspects the new X-Ray machine at Wesu Hospital on 27th October 2021

REASONS FOR REJECTION

1. Low-quality machine

The image production of the X-ray had low quality because it did not include all the required grids. Also, it had an unstable stand for chest procedures which hinders the production of reliable images. Additionally, it bypassed the control panel in the production of X-ray images, which is against the safety requirements of radiation safety. Therefore, the chances of misdiagnosis are high.

2. Low output machine

Wesu Subcounty Hospital serves several patients, and it needs an X-ray generator of 100kv, but the one procured was 50kv. Consequently, the radiographers could not use it for all patients. Also, some procedures like spine and pelvis X-rays could not be done. Moreover, the machine displayed errors every time the radiographer used higher energy x-rays which forced the staff to restart it every time it occurred. Therefore, some patients would still have to get referred to Moi County Referral Hospital, Voi.

Ultimately, this will waste crucial time and resources during medical emergencies that negate the purpose of the X-Ray machine at Wesu.

 3. Lack of printer

The machine was supplied without a printer and the doctors were told they had to go all the way to the x-ray department to look at the images on the computer screen, every time a patient needs an X-Ray. Although they procured a printer later, it is reported that just like the x-ray machine it has technical issues time and again patients report not getting their x-Rays.

It is common knowledge that a digital x-ray machine cannot operate without a printer to produce images. Therefore, this means that those who did the procurement lacked radiography knowledge, and did not work with the radiographers.

The machine has been defective ever since installation to date.

4. Patient radiation safety

Upon scrutiny, the machine displayed poor focusing of X-ray radiation. Also, bad images mean the radiographer will repeat some procedures to get a viable copy. Consequently, it exposed more body parts to patients and the staff. X -Rays are dangerous, and radiographers should minimize the emissions. The radiation protection law under Act cap 243 also stipulates this.

As evidenced by the X-Ray of the governor’s hand on display,there is an obvious defect of X-Ray beam restriction/confinement (see the x-ray)

Governor Samboja’s Right Hand with defective X-Ray Beam restriction

LEGAL ASPECT

1. Breach of procurement regulations

There was a lack of user department input/involvement in the procurement process outlined in The Public Finance Management Act of 2012 and the Public Procurement and Asset Disposal Act of 2015. The radiology department personnel of a hospital understands the machines because they have experience working with them. Therefore, their input is crucial in identifying the correct specifications.

Unfortunately, the county did not involve the radiology department in this process. So, it brought the shortcomings of the project.

Another horrible case is the Kshs 40 million CT SCAN project at Moi Hospital for the 2013/2014 financial year that also went down the drain. The office of the Auditor-General had to flag the sham project. The machine is somewhere lying as junk as the process of finding the culprits who procured it continues. The Coast Radiation Inspection Team identified similar undertakings in acquiring it, and they were afraid the same fate might meet the X-Ray project.

There was also the Ultrasound machines project of financial year 2018/19(Estimated costs of Kshs 50million) which was done in a similar fashion and is now in shambles (The procured machines delivered were not as specified in the RFQ’s).They are currently lying in different health facilities with no qualified personnel to man/operate them.

2. Documents

The documentation of this project is shoddy and unclear. The concerned health department office have not seen anything substantial, yet the commissioning was done in October/November 2021. They have only gotten blank forms for appendage of signatures on committees which the user department members cannot identify the signatories. Moreover, they did not participate in the meetings e.g the tendering committee meeting. That contravenes The PFM Act and the Public Procurement and Disposal act.

Empty Document

3. TTC Governor Deceiving Acts

During a public meeting at Wesu, the TTC Governor stated that he was the first to be X-Rayed. He even displayed images of X-Ray films of his hand.This was unprofessional and unethical. The laws of Radiology stipulate that personnel perform X-Rays only after a client has been reviewed by a medical practitioner, who requests it through a written request form, with adequate justification. It is a pity for such a high profile government official to be involved in such unprofessional exercise.

An X-Ray of a high density part such as spine or pelvis is unachievable, one can confirm as earlier stated that these cases are reffered to Moi hospital.

May the governor do the test exams i.e of the the spine or pelvis, to lead by example in confirming these findings, just like he did of the hand.

In short, there are some X-Rays which cannot be done with the equipment yet it should have the capacity to do so.

The selfish act also exposed the governor to the harmful unwarranted radiation exposure.

4. Malpractice

The operations at Wesu X-Ray department, with the stated shortcomings, amounts to malpractice and breach of professional ethics and regulatory acts as captured by the Radiation protection act cap 243, the act refutes this.

Notably also, the machine being new comes with complete accessories and applications, there was a time during installation that the applications which came with the machine failed, the concerned technician vouched for the applications from a different machine (a different model),which was literally removed from Moi hospital to Wesu.

These activities are unheard of for a new machine which has manufacturers warranty, raising more suspicion on the credibility and reliability of the Wesu equipment (Is it a brand new machine or a used machine?).

5. Closure

The Wesu Subcounty Hospital X-Ray department was closed by the Radiation Protection Board in 2015. The closure was due to the massive radiation leakage from the X-Ray machine, which was hazardous to the personnel and the public. Also, at the time of the commissioning of the X-Ray machine, there was no formal report from the radiation board authorizing the department. (The pdf report will be shared in social media)

Datuzens, wake up no one should have the permission to tamper with your health. However, Governor Granton Samboja’s administration is gambling and playing with the health provision of TTC. Enlighten yourself and make the correct decision when selecting the next batch of leaders.

#MakeAnInformedDecision.

Edited by Maria Nene

more recommended stories