1ST RESPONDENT: TAITA TAVETA COUNTY GOVERNMENT
2ND RESPONDENT: THE TAITA TAVETA COUNTY PUBLIC SERVICE BOARD
This is an in depth view at the looming issue involving the County’s administration pitted against the County Government and the County Public Service Board, in circumstances that have continually been received with plenty of criticism by a few and yet with a lot of silent enthusiasm by the public and groups of sympathizers. At the same time, it is affecting service delivery to the public. This however, should never be the case, since the issue arose long before Samboja’s bid to vie for governorship. The matter has been in existence since 2015, just a year after the administrators’ employment, during former Governor Mruttu’s regime. This was following correspondence between the County Executive, the Public Service Board, and the staff.
Since their employment, administrators questioned the shoddy nature of their contracts, and put the CPSB to task on the same. After some queries, they were told that the County Govt was waiting to engage a pension scheme, after which, they, along with other staff employed on contract terms, would be a absorbed into permanent and pensionable terms.
In March 2015, the Executive, through the County Secretary, instructed the CPSB to convert the terms of all junior members of staff working under contract terms, to be converted to permanent and pensionable terms. This was an executive decision. FYI, by law, the Executive is a principal, and the CPSB is a body corporate whose role as an agent, is to implement the requirement of the principal and advise on human resource matters.
The CPSB wrote to the CS requesting clarity on the cadres of the “junior staff” referred to in their earlier correspondence. The executive replied that it was for ALL staff from Job Group A to Q. They later revised this to be from Job Group A to R.
The officers were then requested by the CPSB to write letters requesting to be converted to Permanent and Pensionable terms, since the Board cited that they could not do a blanket conversion, since not all employees necessarily wanted to be converted to those terms. Pursuant to this the employees were issued with Terms of Service Conversion Forms, which they duly filled and submitted (for those who were willing).
This conversion never took place despite an executive order that the same was to be completed by June 2015.
In June 2015, the Council of Governors and Administrators from the entire COUNTRY met in Bomas of Kenya during the infamous Prof. Lonyangapuo’s bill at the senate that intended to have the terms of county administrators tied to the term of the Governor. The bill never saw the light of the day, as it was determined that a permanent administration cadre in the county governments’ public service is clearly consistent with the values and principles of public service as provided for in Article 232 of the Constitution. It was therefore resolved that the counties who had employed their Administrators on contract terms to change their terms with immediate effect. H. E Mruttu, who was present at the meeting as the Vice Chairman of the Council of Governors at the time, received the message loud and clear.
Pursuant to this, two letters from the COG in July and September 2015, to all Governors, County Secretaries and County Public Service Boards, followed to stress this.
Some counties complied and changed the terms of their administrators. The Taita taveta CPSB declined to do so.
In September 2017, after a general election that saw the incumbent vacate office and a new one sworn in, sitting administrators were shocked and felt aggrieved when their jobs were declared vacant and advertisements seeking to fill their positions were circulated in the national dailies and the County Website. They in turn filed a court case in November 2017 to defend their positions.
This followed a precedent set by Nyeri County Administrators, who faced similar circumstances.
The officers filed a case in the Employment and Labour Relations Court in Mombasa suing the Taita Taveta County Government and the Taita Taveta County Public Service Board – CPSB, for refusing to change their terms from contract to permanent and pensionable employment even after consultations and various correspondence between the County Executive, the County Public Service Board and Staff had been done.
Further to this, the terms other four administrators (Principal Administrative Officers) who were employed on the same date under the same terms except for the contract period, had their contracts expiring by February 2017. They were issued with termination letters, then called by the CPSB and went through suitability tests, after which, three were offered fresh Permanent and Pensionable terms, while one had an extension of contract due to his proximity to retirement age, all without going through the regular competitive process.
Citing the case filed in November 2017, the case was up for highlighting on the 5th of February 2019. In a surprising twist of events, the respondents’ advocate invited the claimants’ advocate for an early morning pre-court meeting. The claimants not being allowed to attend the said meeting, the proceedings of that meeting may be only left to speculation, but suffice it to say , that when the claimants’ lawyer re-appeared, his body language had changed. He then proceeded to the court room, where, without consulting with his clients, consented to a preliminary objection that had been raised by the respondents’ advocate.
The preliminary objection was on section 77 of the County Governments Act 2012 Section 77 (Please Read)
Thereafter the judge ruled that among others, the parties should pursue Alternative Dispute Resolution Mechanism, which the respondent completely neglected, and went on to issue dismissal letters to the claimants. More shocking is that what was said in court was missing in the orders. Whoever typed and printed the orders must have deliberately omitted the order to pursue ADR to suit their own purposes.

Justice Rika said that the file was marked as closed as the parties pursue the ADR. However the admins were shocked to hear that their case was dismissed and not closed. In my understanding when the case file is closed it means the same case can still resurface later, but when it is dismissed it means the facts in the case can’t hold water and that means it dismissed and that it cannot continue.
But the CG changed that narrative that the case was dismissed and immediately issued dismissal letters through the mails without even waiting to see if the claimants will pursue ADR which is the Public Service Commission as it was decided in the court. The dismissal letters were issued by the new CCO public service and administration, a former CPSB member, and in the letter stated that it was under authority from the CPSB.
FYI, the said Board is not fully constituted, hence no quorum to make such a decision. This is because several members are no longer in the board. It is supposed to have seven members, the chairman, the secretary who is the CEO and five other members. The following members have since left the Board
1. Margaret mwachanya went to IEBC
2. Evaline Shighi Mngoda is the new CCO PS&A
3. Elipida Mwakamba who was the secretary is now in water and sanitation department.
4. Isaac Makange is the new CCO Special Programs, Service Delivery Unit
So the board remains with only 3 members
1. Basil Tangai the Chairman
2. Rhoda Mwashighadi (Member) and
3. Stanley Kidondi (Member)
The acting CEO, one Mathew Mwamburi Mfuko is substantively a member of the HR secretariat who is five job groups below the job group of a CEO, he is job group L while a CEO is supposed to be Job group . R This is against HR practices.
Therefore the board acted unfairly and discriminatively and the CG acted unlawfully by rushing to summarily dismiss the officers without pursuing the ADR as per the court orders.
I feel it is important for the general public to know the truth and that whatever happened was unfair rather than the current notion that the admins were on the wrong from the word go.
more recommended stories
TAITA TAVETA: WE CANNOT CONTINUE THIS WAY — A COUNTY GOVERNMENT IN CRISIS OF ACCOUNTABILITYKwaela News Network | Editorial Taita.
DOCUMENT REVIEW: TAITA TAVETA COUNTY CIDP III (2023–2027)A Review of Planned Development Priorities,.
COVID-19 FUNDS IN TAITA TAVETA: YEARS AFTER THE AUDIT, WHO ANSWERED THE QUESTIONS — AND WHO WAS HELD ACCOUNTABLE?As High Court reduces Rodger Ngoo’s.
RUTO’S TAITA TAVETA TOUR: DEVELOPMENT INSPECTION OR PROMISE DELIVERY MISSION?President William Ruto is expected to.
VOI THIRSTS AS LEADERS TRADE STATEMENTS, EXCUSES AND BLAMEYears of promises, unpaid.
MRUGHUA SOCIAL HALL: A DECADE OF WAITING, MILLIONS SPENT, AND STILL NO ANSWERSTen Years Later, Why Is.
SIX-YEAR DEFAMATION CASE ENDS AS COURT AWARDS COSTS TO KWAELA NEWS NETWORK, BUT QUESTIONS OVER COVID-19 FUNDS REMAINVOI, TAITA TAVETA — A six-year.
Family, Power and Public Trust: The Questions Governor Wakujaa Must AnswerThe latest appointments in Taita Taveta.
PETITIONERS FAIL TO PROVE OWNERSHIP OF 1,306 HECTARES AS COURT DISMISSES NDARA B LAND CASECase: Gadiel Mnyambo Mwaisama & Others.
NJORO KUBWA OR MZIMA PHASE II? WEIGHING TAITA TAVETA’S BIG WATER OPTIONSWater has long been one.
WHY KENYANS ARE TURNING AGAINST SAFARICOM OVER SURVEILLANCE FEARSFor years, Safaricom has enjoyed enormous.
FIRES, FEAR AND FAILURE: THE HARD QUESTIONS TAITA TAVETA SCHOOLS MUST ANSWERA disturbing pattern is emerging in.
PARIS JUU YA MACHOZI YETU: AIBU YA VIONGOZI WALIOSAHAU WATU WAOKatika wakati ambapo wananchi wa.
ISANGAIWISHI DEVELOPMENT COMMUNITY OFFICIAL STATEMENT ON LAND OWNERSHIP, HISTORICAL RECORD, AND DEVELOPMENT1. Introduction The Isangaiwishi Development Community.
AUDIT SHOCKER: HUNDREDS OF MILLIONS IN WORKERS’ DEDUCTIONS UNACCOUNTED FOR AS FINANCE SHAKE UP ROCKS TAITA TAVETABy Kwaela News Network Investigations Desk.
COURT EXPOSES ILLEGAL IMPEACHMENT: TAITA TAVETA COUNTY ASSEMBLY FAULTED FOR RUSHED, UNCONSTITUTIONAL REMOVAL OF SPEAKER MWAMBURIMombasa, Kenya — In a damning.

Comprehensive