WHY MOMBASA DESERVES MZIMA WATER OVER COSTLY DESALINATION EXPERIMENTS

Laying a Pipeline in Botswana

As Mombasa continues to grapple with chronic water shortages, the government’s increasing focus on desalination projects raises serious questions about priorities, sustainability, and long-term value for citizens. While desalination is often presented as a modern solution to water scarcity, the decision to sideline the expansion of the Mzima water system in favor of treating Indian Ocean water deserves critical scrutiny.

At the heart of this debate lies a simple but powerful reality: Mzima Springs already provide a naturally clean, reliable, and significantly underutilized freshwater source. With an estimated output exceeding 400 million liters per day—of which less than 10% is currently exploited—the springs represent one of Kenya’s most valuable natural water assets.

A Question of Logic and Priorities

It is difficult to justify why a government facing fiscal constraints would prioritize desalination—one of the most energy-intensive and expensive water production methods—over expanding access to an existing freshwater source.

Desalination plants require:

  • High capital investment (tens of billions of shillings)
  • Continuous energy input
  • Complex maintenance systems

In contrast, Mzima water flows naturally and requires far less processing. The main challenge lies not in the water itself, but in the infrastructure needed to deliver it efficiently to Mombasa.

The Real Issue: Infrastructure Neglect

The argument that Mzima expansion is “not viable” often masks a deeper systemic problem: decades of underinvestment in water infrastructure. Mombasa currently loses nearly half of its water through leaks, illegal connections, and outdated systems—so-called non-revenue water.

Instead of addressing these inefficiencies, the government appears to be pursuing a parallel system that does not fix the root problem. Building a desalination plant without repairing the distribution network risks creating an expensive supply feeding into a broken system.

Financial Convenience vs Public Interest

From an investment standpoint, desalination projects may appear more attractive. They are centralized, easier to meter, and offer predictable revenue streams under public-private partnerships. However, what is financially convenient for investors is not always what is economically or socially optimal for the public.

Mzima-based solutions, while requiring more coordination and upfront infrastructure work, promise:

  • Lower long-term operating costs
  • Greater sustainability
  • Reduced dependence on external energy inputs
  • Environmental and Public Perception Concerns

Although desalination technology can produce safe drinking water, it begins with heavily saline and increasingly polluted ocean water. Coastal waters near major ports like Mombasa are exposed to:

  • Industrial discharge
  • Marine traffic pollution
  • Urban runoff

Treating such water to potable standards is technically feasible—but costly and energy-intensive. This raises a broader question: why invest heavily in cleaning degraded water when a clean, natural alternative already exists?

A Missed Opportunity for Sustainable Development

Investing in Mzima Phase II would not only improve water access but also strengthen national infrastructure, create jobs, and promote equitable resource use. It would signal a commitment to maximizing Kenya’s natural advantages rather than bypassing them.

Critics increasingly view the repeated shelving of Mzima projects as a symptom of short-term planning—where highly visible, capital-intensive projects are favored over less glamorous but more impactful system improvements.

Conclusion

Mombasa does not lack water—it lacks effective delivery and management. The continued emphasis on desalination risks diverting attention and resources away from a more practical, sustainable solution already within reach.

A balanced strategy is essential. However, prioritizing desalination over the expansion and optimization of Mzima water infrastructure is difficult to defend on economic, environmental, or social grounds.

If the goal is long-term water security for Mombasa, the path forward should begin not in the ocean—but at Mzima.

more recommended stories