The recent court decision in Wisdom Mwamburi vs Taita Taveta County Assembly, the Clerk & Others has provided an important civic lesson for the people of Taita Taveta: political decisions do not occur in a vacuum, and when unlawful, unconstitutional, and unfair proceedings take place, administrative responsibility must be interrogated.
At the centre of this responsibility is the Clerk of the County Assembly.
THE CLERK IS NOT A MESSENGER — HE IS THE GATEKEEPER
In Kenya’s devolved system, the Clerk of a County Assembly is not a ceremonial officer. He is:
- The chief administrative officer of the Assembly
- The principal adviser on procedure and law
- The custodian of Standing Orders and records
- The accounting officer responsible for lawful use of public funds
In simple terms, nothing becomes official Assembly business without passing through the Clerk’s office.
That is why courts have consistently held that:
A Clerk who enables an illegal process cannot hide behind “instructions of the House.”
The Clerk’s legal duty is not obedience to political pressure, but obedience to the Constitution, statute, and procedure.
WHAT THE COURT PROVED IN THE WISDOM MWAMBURI CASE
In the Mwamburi case, the court conclusively found that the impeachment process was:
- Illegal
- Unconstitutional
- Unfair
This finding is not abstract. It has direct implications.
An illegal process does not become legal because MCAs voted.
An unconstitutional process does not become constitutional because it was rushed.
An unfair process does not become fair because it suited political interests.
For such a process to proceed:
- Notices had to be processed
- Timelines had to be ignored or misapplied
- Records had to be generated
- Decisions had to be implemented
All these functions fall squarely within the administrative domain of the Clerk.
WHY EXPERIENCE MATTERS
Mr. Gadiel Maghanga has served as Clerk since 2013. This long tenure carries weight.
Experience does not automatically imply bad faith — but it eliminates the defence of ignorance.
A Clerk with over a decade of experience:
- Knows impeachment thresholds and timelines
- Understands fair hearing requirements
- Is aware of constitutional safeguards
- Knows the financial consequences of unlawful decisions
This is why the following conclusion is both fair and unavoidable:
“Given his long experience, the Clerk bears serious administrative responsibility for allowing an illegal, unconstitutional, and unfair process to proceed, whether through negligence, carelessness, or failure to stand firm against political pressure.”
The Mwamburi judgment confirms that such a process did proceed — and was later struck down by the court.
THE PATTERN: DISCIPLINE OF DISSENTING MCAs
The problem did not end with the illegal impeachment.
Following the ouster of Hon. Wisdom Mwamburi, the Assembly reportedly took retaliatory disciplinary actions against MCAs who did not support the impeachment. The case of Hon. Dorcas Mlughu, MCA for Rong’e Ward, stands out.
She was allegedly:
- Removed from committees
- Denied salaries and allowances
This raises another core civic principle:
MCAs cannot be punished for how they vote
Voting is a constitutional duty, protected by:
- Freedom of expression
- Political rights
- Representative democracy
Committee membership and salaries are not tools of punishment. Withholding them without due process is arbitrary, unconstitutional, and unlawful.
Once again, such actions could not occur without administrative facilitation.
WHY “THE HOUSE DECIDED” IS NOT A DEFENCE
One of the most dangerous misconceptions in public governance is the idea that:
“If the House resolved, it must be legal.”
That is false.
The Clerk is expected to:
- Warn the House when it is acting unlawfully
- Refuse to process defective motions
- Decline to implement unconstitutional resolutions
- Record objections and advise on consequences
When a Clerk fails to do this, the institution is exposed — legally and financially.
The financial burden now facing Taita Taveta County, including payment of salaries for months lost due to an illegal impeachment, is a direct consequence of administrative failure.
CIVIC LESSON FOR TAITA TAVETA RESIDENTS
This case teaches three critical lessons:
- Procedure is protection. When procedure collapses, rights collapse.
- Administrators matter as much as politicians. Bad politics succeeds when administration looks away.
- Accountability is institutional, not personal vendetta. Questioning the Clerk’s role is not witch-hunting — it is civic duty.
CONCLUSION: RESPONSIBILITY WITHOUT ESCAPE
The courts have now spoken. The impeachment was illegal. The process was unconstitutional. The outcome was unfair.
It is therefore reasonable, lawful, and necessary for residents to demand answers to one central question:
How did such proceedings pass through the administrative gatekeeping of the County Assembly?
The Clerk stands at the heart of House business. With that position comes authority, trust, and responsibility.
And where responsibility exists, accountability must follow.
more recommended stories
THE ERA OF POLITICAL EUPHORIA IN TAITA TAVETA COUNTY IS OVERThe days when political party.
TAITA TAVETA: KSh 9.86 MILLION IN SALARIES, TWO ALLEGED FORGED DEGREES — WHO VERIFIED THE QUALIFICATIONS?KNN INVESTIGATIVE EDITORIAL | PUBLIC.
TAVEVO: THE GRAND WATER SCAM DRAINING TAITA TAVETA COUNTY DRY?Before demanding more water from.
USAWA NI SAWA: A PRINCIPLE THAT MUST TRANSCEND NATIONAL AND COUNTY POLITICSPicture a grand tapestry, woven with.
KAUNTI YA TAITA TAVETA ITAKWISHA KAMA HUU UONGOZI UTAENDELEA BAADA YA UCHAGUZI WA 2027Taita Taveta imebarikiwa kwa utajiri wa.
THE CROSSROADS OF TAITA-TAVETA: CHOOSING THE NEXT PATHFor decades, the conversation surrounding leadership.
KSh600 FOR A WHOLE DAY: HOW TAITA TAVETA’S “BODA BODA CROWD” MAY HAVE TURNED RUTO’S TOUR INTO A POLITICAL PHOTO SHOOTThere is a rather amusing —.
GODOMA FINALLY GETS ITS TITLE DEEDS — A RIGHT LONG OVERDUEThe issuance of title deeds.
CHURU CHURU PROJECTS VS REAL DEVELOPMENTWhy Taita Taveta Must Stop.
2027 BEGINS EARLY: THE MWANGOLO-BWIRE RIVALRY EXPOSES A GENERATIONAL DIVIDEThe political war between Principal Secretary.
CORRUPTION: THE SILENT TAX CRUSHING ORDINARY KENYANSA Nation Paying Twice for.
THE ODM-UDA COALITION: A MARRIAGE OF CONVENIENCE, NOT CONVICTIONWhen the Orange Democratic Movement and.
SUMMARY OF THE TAITA TAVETA COUNTY FY 2026 / 2027 BUDGET ESTIMATESThe County Government of Taita Taveta.
WHOEVER FEEDS YOU CONTROLS YOU: SANKARA’S WARNING AFRICA REFUSES TO HEAR“He who feeds you, controls you.”.
LEGAL OPINION EXPOSES IRREGULAR COUNTY APPOINTMENT: QUESTIONS MOUNT FOR GOVERNOR WAKUJAA’S ADMINISTRATIONFresh questions are emerging over governance.
GOVERNORS NEED STRONG ASSEMBLIES, NOT CHEERLEADERSMy elder sister, Hon. Dorcas.

Leave a Comment