COURT EXPOSES ILLEGAL IMPEACHMENT: TAITA TAVETA COUNTY ASSEMBLY FAULTED FOR RUSHED, UNCONSTITUTIONAL REMOVAL OF SPEAKER MWAMBURI

Taita Taveta County Assembly Speaker Wisdom Kazungu Mwamburi

Mombasa, Kenya — In a damning judgment that lays bare serious governance failures, the Employment and Labour Relations Court has nullified the impeachment of Taita Taveta County Assembly Speaker Hon. Wisdom Mwamburi Kazungu, declaring the entire process unconstitutional, unlawful, and procedurally unfair.

In a ruling delivered by Justice Ocharo Kebira, the Court found that the County Assembly deliberately ignored the law, violated Standing Orders, and trampled on constitutional guarantees of fair hearing and due process in its hurried removal of the Speaker on 3rd July 2024.

The Court has now reinstated Hon. Mwamburi as the bona fide Speaker with immediate effect and ordered the Assembly to pay all withheld salaries from July 2024 to date, a decision with major financial and political implications for the county.


A PROCESS “DESIGNED TO FAIL THE LAW”

At the heart of the case was the speed and recklessness with which the impeachment was conducted.

The Speaker was served with an impeachment notice on 2nd July 2024 at 3:59 pm and summoned to defend himself less than 17 hours later, on the morning of 3rd July.

Yet the law is explicit:

  • Standing Order 82(6) requires the Speaker to be given seven (7) days to respond in writing.

  • Investigations and debate cannot lawfully proceed before that period lapses.

The Court held that compressing the entire impeachment process into less than 24 hours was not just irregular, but illegal.

Justice Kebira likened the Assembly’s conduct to:

“A court proceeding to hear and determine a civil suit before the time for filing a response has expired.”


FAIR HEARING DENIED, CONSTITUTION VIOLATED

The Assembly argued that numbers were sufficient and that the Speaker had an opportunity to be heard. The Court rejected this argument outright.

Key findings include:

  • The Speaker was never given the mandatory seven days

  • Investigations were concluded before he could respond

  • His illness and formal request for adjournment were ignored

  • Sending an advocate merely to seek adjournment did not amount to legal representation

The Court ruled that this conduct violated Articles 47 and 50 of the Constitution, which guarantee fair administrative action and fair hearing, even in political or disciplinary processes.

Importantly, the Court dismissed claims that Article 50 only applies to criminal trials, relying on binding Supreme Court jurisprudence affirming that disciplinary and impeachment proceedings are equally subject to constitutional fairness.


NUMBERS DON’T OVERRIDE THE CONSTITUTION

A critical message from the judgment is that political majorities do not excuse illegality.

The Judge was emphatic:

  • Section 11 of the County Governments Act cannot be cherry-picked

  • Standing Orders and constitutional safeguards are mandatory, not optional

  • Speed and political convenience cannot override the rule of law

The Court warned that to uphold such an impeachment would be to legitimise abuse of power by County Assemblies.


STRONG ORDERS, SERIOUS CONSEQUENCES

The Court issued the following binding orders:

  1. The impeachment of Hon. Wisdom Mwamburi was unconstitutional, unlawful, and procedurally unfair

  2. He is reinstated as Speaker with immediate effect

  3. All unpaid salaries and benefits from July 2024 must be paid

  4. Costs awarded against the County Assembly

These orders raise unavoidable questions for taxpayers in Taita Taveta:

  • Who authorised the illegal process?

  • Who will account for public funds now payable as salary arrears?

  • Will any Assembly officials be held personally responsible?


A WIDER GOVERNANCE WARNING

This judgment goes beyond one individual.

It is a stern warning to County Assemblies across Kenya that impeachment is not a political shortcut, but a constitutionally regulated process.

The Court has reaffirmed a critical principle:

Power exercised without due process is illegitimate—no matter how popular or numerically supported.

As Taita Taveta residents grapple with service delivery challenges, the ruling re-ignites debate on accountability, abuse of power, and the cost of unconstitutional decisions borne by the public.


Kwaela News Network will continue to follow:

  • Implementation of the Court orders

  • Financial implications for the County Assembly

  • Accountability for those who engineered the illegal impeachment

more recommended stories