REPORT: TAITA TAVETA DG H.E. HON CHRISTINE KILALO AUTHORISED PAYMENTS OF SH3M TO REAL TIME GROUP FOR NO WORK DONE

Taita Taveta Deputy Governor H.E. Hon Christine Kilalo

It has emerged that the Taita Taveta county deputy Governor H.E. Hon Christine Kilalo, authorised payment of Sh3M to Real Time Group to do feasibility Study on Healthanangement System.

However, to date the Group has not delivered as per the agreement.

How can the County Government recover the Sh3M paid upfront?

Why did the DG authorise the payment despite the fact that Health  Department Team advised her not to do so?

What were the DG’s interest in outsourcing the job yet it could be done internally?

Why wasn’t the contract advertised for competitive bidding and why did the DG go the single sourcing way?

What were the DG’s interest in outsourcing the job yet it could be done internally?

These are some of the few questions that need answers

Below is the report.

REPORT ON REAL TIME GROUP FEASIBILITY STUDY ON HEALTH MANAGEMNT SYSTEM

Preamble

The Real Time Group was awarded a Tender to carry out a feasibility study within the County health facilities regarding the Health Management Systems. The objectives of the study were:

Undertake detailed, assessment on the current status of HMIS implementation in the department of health

Establish the available Health Information System in the department of Health and the extent of their utilization

Assess gaps and needs of HMIS infrastructure and Human Resource for its implementation.

Establish a possible applicable Integrated Health Information System which can interphase with KHIS, IHRIS and any other operable information System in the County Health Department.

Establish the cost requirement of installation (Capital expenditure), implementation and maintenance cost (Operational Expenditure) of the proposed Integrated Health Information System.

Establish Strengths, Weaknesses, opportunities and threats on the available and feasible Health Information System software’s and hardware’s.

Establish a cost best analysis and a sustainability model of the proposed Integrated Health Information System.

Establish the risk associated with the implementation of the Integrated Health Information System in regards to PESTEL model.

The tendering process

The tender process was not conducted well as per the Public Procurement and Disposal Act, 2016, since there was no tender advertised and hence Real Time Group was single sourced as there was no competitive bidding. The Department of Health had initiated a competitive process by preparing a request for proposal (see Copy attached and marked Appendix I) and later advertised for the tender but was later on asked to drop the process after Real Time Group signed an agreement with the County Government.

The process of conducting the feasibility study

Following the signing of the agreement between the County Government and Real Time Group, the later requested the county to do introduction letters to the Hospital and Sub county Health managers and also the provincial administration. This is because, while conducting the study, the team needed to interact and possibly interview Healthcare workers and possibly members of the Public. To this end, the County Department of health did the letters (See copies attached and marked appendix II a,b,c), which were emailed to Real Time Group.

Real Time Group never issued a schedule of their activities to this department and hence, the health facilities had to wait for researchers indefinitely.

The Team came to the county on 5th December and paid a Courtesy call to H.E The Deputy Governor’s Office. After they were received H.E Deputy Governor brought them to Wundanyi, where she was to introduce them to the CECM for Health. Upon reaching Wundanyi, they found the CECM at the County Assembly where he was attending a meeting which was organised to listen to certain group of Investors.

The CECM was called to come out to meet the Real Time Group within the County Assembly premises. After meeting the team, it was agreed that the team, should visit the Wundanyi Sub County Health offices, where they were to meet the Wundanyi Sub County Health Management Team, which was to show Real Time Group team the directions to Wesu sub county Hospital. From there the team was expected to move to the rest of the hospitals to conduct the study.

Payment

The count government did a part payment of Kshs. 3.0 million (50% of the contract sum i.e., Kshs. 6.o million) as per the contract agreement.

Reports from the hospitals

The matrix below depicts the report from hospitals on the visits done by Real Time Group to the hospital/s and the activities done, if any. This report is at 6th February, 2023.

Recommendations

In view of the above, it is evident that, so far, the Real Time group has not discharged its mandate as per the contract and therefore we recommend the following:

An official letter be done, asking them to fast track the process observing the timelines as per the contract agreement.

If the company does not show any motion in this matter after the letter, a demand letter be done, asking them to refund the money paid to them and then the procedure of terminating the contract be applied.

Gifton Mkaya

CECM-Health Services

more recommended stories