REPORT ON THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS OF TAITA TAVETA COUNTY EXECUTIVE- FY 2023/2024

Basis for Qualified Opinion

  1. Variances in Transfer to Other Government Entities

The statement of receipts and payments and as disclosed in Note 6 to the financial statements reflect Kshs.779,457,444 as transfers to other Government entities. Included in the transfers amount are transfers from the County Executive amounts of Kshs.373,103,336 and Kshs.79,696,527 to Tavevo Water and Sanitation Company Limited and Level 4 Hospitals while the respective institutions financial statements reflected amounts of Kshs.148,006,875 and Kshs.900,000, resulting to unexplained variances of Kshs.225,096,461 and Kshs.78,796,527 respectively.

In the circumstances, the accuracy and completeness of the transfer to other Government entities of Kshs.779,457,444 could not be confirmed.

2. Transactions in System Payments but not Processed in Payment Details

The statement of receipts and payments reflects total payments amount of Kshs.5,007,872,796. However, analysis of the System Payment Reports processed against payments made revealed that there were forty (40) transactions amounting to Kshs.77,553,567 that were paid but not captured in the IFMIS Payment Details Report as at 30 June, 2024. Voided payment vouchers, requests to void transactions, Further, The National Treasury approval and Exchequer requisitions from the Controller of Budget were not provided for audit. No reason was provided for the omission of transactions totalling Kshs.77,553,567 from the payment details.

In the circumstances, the accuracy and completeness of payments totalling Kshs.5,007,872,796 could not be confirmed.

3. Misclassification of Expenditure – Fuel, Oil and Lubricants

Note 9 to the financial statements reflects acquisition of assets amount of Kshs.228,228,347 out of which an amount of Kshs.1,300,000 was misclassified expenditure incurred on fuel, oil and lubricants instead of being charged under use of goods and services.

In the circumstances, the accuracy and completeness of acquisition of assets of Kshs.228,228,347 could not be confirmed.

4.Unexplained Variances on Statutory Contributions

The statement of receipts and payments reflects compensation of employees of Kshs.2,661,985,420. Review of human resource records revealed that the County Executive deducted National Health Insurance Fund (NHIF) and National Social Security Fund (NSSF) employee contributions totalling Kshs.45,333,700 and Kshs.60,694,320 respectively. However, third party confirmation from NHIF and NSSF showed that the total amount remitted as employee contribution was Kshs.45,259,450 and Kshs.49,765,920 resulting to an unexplained variance of Kshs.74,250 and Kshs.10,928,400 respectively as unremitted deductions. Further, Management did not remit the NHIF matching employer contribution of Kshs.45,333,700 as required by Section 15(2)(d) of the NHIF Act, 2022.

In the circumstances, the completeness and accuracy of the compensation of employees of Kshs.2,661,985,420 could not be confirmed.

5. Unsupported Expenditure

  • Purchase of Certified Seeds, Breeding Stock and Live Animals

The statement of receipts and payments reflects acquisition of assets amount of Kshs.228,228,347 which includes expenditure for purchase of certified seeds, breeding stock and live animals amount of Kshs.17,286,598. Included in the amount is an expenditure of Kshs.599,600 in respect of the supply and delivery of seeds to Kaloleni ward which was not supported with a list of beneficiaries. Further, payments totalling Kshs.680,000 made to various community groups for purchase of tree seedlings, pitting and planting was also not supported with acknowledgement receipt of the items.

In the circumstances, the regularity of the expenditure of Kshs.1,279,600 on purchase of certified seeds, breeding stock and live animals could not be confirmed.

5.2 Routine Maintenance – Vehicles and Other Transport Equipment

The statement of receipt and payments reflects use of goods and services amount of Kshs.915,939,831. The amount includes Kshs.11,276,843 spent on routine maintenance – vehicles and other transport equipment. However, review of ten (10) sampled payments revealed the following anomalies;

  1. Payment for breakdown services for the recovery of a vehicle of amount of Kshs.354,000 was as a consequence of direct procurement in violation of Section 103(1) of the Public Procurement and Asset Disposal Act, 2015.
  2. Motor vehicle maintenance log was not provided in support of payment for motor vehicle repair and maintenance amount of Kshs.929,482, overhaul repair and maintenance of environment truck vehicle amounting to Kshs.661,500, repair and maintenance of fire engine vehicle at Kshs.675,550, all totalling 2,266,532.
  • Payment for motor vehicle repair and maintenance for a vehicle amounting to Kshs.929,482 was based on a proforma invoice and no receipt was provided for the advance payment.

In the circumstances, the regularity of the expenditure of Kshs.3,550,014 on routine maintenance – vehicles and other transport equipment could not be confirmed.

5.3 Printing, Advertising and Information Supplies and Services

The statement of receipt and payments reflects use of goods and services amount of Kshs.915,939,831. The amount includes expenditure for printing, advertising and information supplies and services amount of Kshs.8,141,874. The County Executive paid an amount of Kshs.1,800,000 for Land Use Plan Report and Map Completion on 30 June, 2024. However, the expenditure was not included in the procurement plan or budgeted for and the payment was not supported with tender documents including requisition for the services, the evaluation report and professional opinion.

In the circumstances, the regularity of the expenditure of Kshs.1,800,000 on printing, advertising and information supplies and services could not be confirmed.

6. Unsupported Expenditure on Construction of Roads

The statement of receipts and payments and as disclosed in Note 9 to financial statements reflects acquisition of assets of Kshs.228,228,347 out of which an amount of Kshs.24,638,939 was incurred on construction of roads where the following anomalies were observed;

6.1 Murraming of Ebenezer Kilimanjaro Konoike Road

Review of expenditure records revealed that Management contracted a firm at a sum of Kshs.999,980 for murraming works on Ebenezer Konoike Road. However, the contract was not provided and the tender documents reviewed reflect a two (2) year framework agreement for hire of road maintenance equipment and not grading and gravelling of Ebenezer – Konoike road.

6.2 Gravelling and Murraming of Mata Ward Feeder Roads

Management contracted a firm for gravelling and murraming of Mata Ward feeder roads at a sum of Ksh.2,400,000. However, the tender opening minutes, professional opinion, letter of notification of award and letter of acceptance provided for audit were for a two (2) year framework agreement for hire of road maintenance equipment and not for gravelling and murraming of Mata feeder roads.

6.3 Unsupported Supply and Delivery of Fuel and Lubricants for Routine Maintenance for Ward Roads

Review of payment records revealed that the County Executive procured fuel and lubricants for routine maintenance of ward roads. However, the following anomalies were observed;

6.3.1 Routine Maintenance for Kaloleni Ward Roads

The County Executive procured the supply and delivery of fuel and lubricants worth Kshs.1,500,000 on 18 January, 2024. The requisition and the payment voucher described the expenditure as routine maintenance for Kaloleni Ward roads. However, fuel consumption statements and fuel detail orders in support of the fuel drawn and inspection reports on maintenance works were not provided for audit.

6.3.2 Routine Maintenance for Mata Ward Roads

The County Executive incurred an amount of Kshs.1,300,000 for the supply and delivery of fuel and lubricants on 25 June, 2024. The evaluation was done on 08 November, 2022 and a two (2) year framework agreement signed between the County Government and the supplier on 24 November, 2022. However, the payment was not supported with the evaluation report, letter of acceptance, delivery acknowledgement of fuel and lubricants, fuel detail orders and the supplier’s statement.

6.3.3 Routine Maintenance for Mboghoni Ward Roads

The County Executive paid for fuel and lubricants for Mboghoni Ward roads routine maintenance worth Kshs.1,000,000 on 28 June, 2024. However, the payments was not supported with the details of the motor vehicles fueled, fuel consumption statements and fuel detail orders.

6.4 Unsupported Provisional Sum on Rehabilitation of Ngambenyi Bungule Road

The Department of Public Works and Infrastructure tendered for the rehabilitation of Ngambenyi Bungule road and the lowest evaluated bidder was awarded the tender at a contract sum of Kshs.1,988,878. However, project inspection carried out on 20 September, 2024 and review of the bill of quantities revealed that provisional sum of Kshs.120,000 allocated for material testing was not supported by evidence of laboratory test results on materials used. Additionally, there was no concrete works done despite provision for Kshs.297,600 for the same.

In the circumstances, the accuracy, completeness and occurrence of Kshs.7,617,580 could not be confirmed.

Emphasis of Matter

  1. Budgetary Control and Performance

The statement of comparison of budget and actual amounts reflects final receipt budget and actual amounts on comparable basis of Kshs.6,660,495,041 and Kshs.5,070,235,235 respectively, resulting in under-funding of Kshs.1,590,259,806 or 24% of the budget. However, the County Executive spent an amount of Kshs.5,007,872,796 against actual receipts of Kshs.5,070,235,235 resulting in an under-expenditure of Kshs.62,362,439 of the actual receipts.

The under-funding and under-expenditure affected the planned activities and may have impacted negatively on service delivery to the public.

My opinion is not modified in respect of this matter.

Other Matter

  1. Unresolved Prior Year Matters

In the audit report of the previous year, several issues were raised under the Report on the Financial Statements, Report on Lawfulness and Effectiveness in Use of Public Resources and Report on Effectiveness of Internal Controls, Risk Management and Governance. However, although Management has indicated that the issues have been resolved, no evidence was provided in support of this position.

REPORT ON LAWFULNESS AND EFFECTIVENESS IN USE OF PUBLIC RESOURCES

Basis for Conclusion

  1. Unsupported Pending Payables

Note 20 to the financial statements on other important disclosures reflects accounts and staff payables balances carried forward amounts of Kshs.1,374,955,773 and Kshs.800,170,135 respectively, both totalling Kshs.2,175,125,908. However, analysis of detailed ledger indicating order and invoices issued and staff details which includes name and personal number were not provided for audit. In addition, Annex 3 to the financial statements on staff payables balance amount of Kshs.800,170,135 did not show how much was owed to the senior and middle management and unionisable employees. This was contrary to the reporting requirement prescribed and published by the Public Sector Accounting Standards Board (PSASB).

In the circumstances, Management was in breach of the PSASB reporting requirements.

10. Mining Operations

  • Unlicensed Mining Sites

Records maintained reflected that the County Executive had one hundred and sixty- one (161) mining sites located in the four (4) Sub Counties, registered between the 1997 and 2020. However, there was no evidence provided to confirm whether mining licenses had been granted to one hundred and fifty-eight (158) companies as provided by Section 180(1) of the Mining Act, 2016 which states that the Cabinet Secretary will not grant a license unless the applicant has submitted site plans, mitigation and rehabilitation or mine-closure plans and that the Mining permits issued were renewed as required by Section 142(1) of the Mining Act, No 2016 which states that the term of renewal of a mining permit is to be specified in the permit but not to exceed five years or the remaining life of the mine, whichever is the shorter.

Further, there was no evidence that the County Executive had complied with Section 101(2) of the Mining Act, 2016 which requires submission and approval of an environmental and social impact assessment report and environmental management plan for the duration of the mining license to the National Environment Management Authority, before licensing.

In the circumstances, Management was in breach of the law.

10.2  Undisclosed Information on Volume and Revenue Generated from Mining

Review of mining records provided revealed that quantities of minerals generated and revenues paid to the County Executive on the mining and mineral related activities was not disclosed, contrary to Section 119(3) of the Mining Act, 2016 which requires regulations made to provide accountable and transparent mechanisms of reporting mining and mineral related activities, including revenues paid to the Government by mineral rights holders and production volumes under each license or permit.

Further, details of community development agreement where the mining operations were being carried out was not provided for audit, contrary to Section 109(i) of the Mining Act, 2016 which requires a mining license holder to sign a community development agreement where mining operations are to carried out as prescribed by the regulations. Additionally, twenty-nine (29) mining companies in Voi Sub-County did not indicate the category of mineral being mined provided by Section 79(2) of the Mining Act, 2016 which requires keeping of records and details of minerals discovered, results of geochemical or geophysical analysis obtained, financial statements and books of accounts.

In the circumstances, Management was in breach of the law.

11.Non-Compliance with Fiscal Responsibility Principle on Wage Bill

The statement of receipts and payments reflects an expenditure amount of Kshs.2,661,985,420 on compensation of employees representing 52% of the total revenue of Kshs.5,070,235,235. This was contrary to Regulation 25(1) of the Public Finance Management (County Governments) Regulations, 2015 which requires the County Executive to set a wage and benefits limit for public officers which should not exceed 35% of the total revenues received.

In the circumstances, Management was in breach of the law.

12.Incomplete Project Documentation

Review of a sample of seven (7) projects totalling Kshs.44,982,286 revealed that the respective projects files had omissions in recording and filing of project documents such as site minutes, certificates of works done, payment vouchers and inspection and acceptance certificates. This was contrary to Section 151(2)(h) of the Public Procurement and Asset Disposal Act, 2015 which provides that the contract implementation team shall be responsible for ensuring that the contract is complete, prior to closing the contract file including all handover procedures, transfers of title if need be and that the final retention payment has been made. Further, there were no progress reports contrary to Section 152 of the Public Procurement Asset Disposal Act, 2015 which provide that the head of the procurement function shall prepare monthly progress reports of all procurement contracts of the procuring entity and submit them to the accounting officer.

In the circumstances, Management was in breach of the law.

13.Incomplete, Stalled and Abandoned Projects

During the month of August, 2024, seven (7) projects with cumulative payments amounting to Kshs.44,982,286 were verified. One (1) project with cumulative payments of Kshs.1,298,072 was complete but not in use, two (2) projects with cumulative payments of Kshs.34,701,000 were incomplete; one (1) project with cumulative payments of Kshs.1,996,358 had stalled and two (2) projects with cumulative payments of Kshs.3,996,750 were abandoned.

In the circumstances, value for money for the incomplete, stalled and abandoned projects could not be confirmed.

14.Lack of Human Resource and Recruitment Plans

During the year under review, two hundred and one (201) new staff were hired by the County Executive. However, no annual recruitment plans including evidence of budgetary allocation was provided for audit. This was contrary to Section B.2(2) of the County Human Resource Management Policy and Manual, 2020 that requires, County Departments to develop annual recruitment plans backed by evidence of budgetary allocation which is forwarded to the County Public Service Board at the beginning of each financial year to enable it plan to fill the vacancies. In addition, Management did not prepare human resource plan to support achievement of goals and objectives in the strategic plan as is required of Section B.2(1) of the County Human Resource Management Policy and Manual, 2020.

In the circumstances, Management was in breach of the law.

REPORT ON THE EFFECTIVENESS OF INTERNAL CONTROLS, RISK MANAGEMENT AND GOVERNANCE

Basis for Conclusion

  1. Lack of Ownership Documents

The County Executive assets register reflects six hundred and sixty-five (665) parcels of land distributed across the departments. However, the ownership documents were not provided for audit. Further, there was no evidence that the County Executive had carried out physical inspection and verification of the assets during the year under review. Further, physical inspection and verification on September, 2024 revealed that four (4) parcels of land in Taveta Sub-County Mboghoni Trading centre, Kitoghoto trading centre, Kimorigo trading centre and Kimala trading centre did not have signage, thereby exposing the land to encroachment. In addition, the County Executive had two hundred and fifty-three (253) motor vehicles whose ownership documents were not provided for audit.

In the circumstances, the ownership and safety of the assets could not be confirmed.

more recommended stories