LEAKED: COUNTY GOVERNMENT OF TAITA TAVETA LEGAL STATUS REPORT

Mr Edwin Chahilu - Legal advisor Taita Taveta County

 

  1. OVERVIEW

A legal department/office is a cog in any institution, corporate entity, semi-autonomous government agency, a national government department and county government(s).  Previously, a legal office was viewed as the nerve centre for disputes but today it is recognized as a governance unit that influences decision-making, policy crafting, legislation, corporate governance retinues, arbitration and more than ever before constitutional interpretation.



The Constitution of Kenya (2010) midwifed devolution thus recognized both the National and County Governments.  The latter were to be guided by both provisions of among others:-

  • the County Government Act, 2012
  • the Public Finance Management Act, 2012
  • the then Transition County Allocation Act
  • the then Transition County to Devolved Government Act, 2012
  • the National Government Co-ordination Act, 2013
  • the Inter-Governmental Relations Act, 2012
  • the Public Private Partnership Act 2013
  • the Public Procurement & Disposal Act, 2016

Meaning there were more powers transferred from the National Governments to County Governments, and also the numerous guiding pieces of legislation meant there was need for constant interpretation of the aforesaid laws.  Importantly, the constitution envisaged a situation where the County Governments will ensure continuous development of “their own” laws so as to ensure proper governance and revenue collection.  As such, more lawyers were required to give guidance to the processes at both Executive and County Assembly levels so as to smoothen the road towards the gains of devolution.

Governors were thus allowed to directly appoint legal advisors (I have a valid appointment letter and contract with the County Government) to accord them all the necessary legal advice on pertinent issues, in addition most counties have since established legal directorates to spearhead legislation and dispute resolution mainly.  However as time went by, most counties established the office of the County Attorney.

It is worth noting that the office of the County Attorney Bill No. 3 of 2018 is already before Senate awaiting approval for assent into law by the National Assembly.

The legal advisor as things stand, oversees all legal and external affairs matters including litigation, compliance, routine contractual matters, advisory opinions and the legislative, regulatory, administrative and policy matters.  Yes, a very full plate of risks, threats and issues to deal with.

Perhaps being a non-revenue generator, the legal services under the Governor’s office have continuously received meagre allocations. I put it on record that, a legal advisor  is not in any way an AIE holder nor does he have standing imprest and as such, has no control over any vote whatsoever and importantly, all legal fees payable to contracted external lawyers goes through the normal processes at finance and the same are retrievable for record purposes.

The legal Advisor’s office must interact with internal clients and departments (such as procurement, finance, trade, mining, etc.), the executive committee, subject matter experts, regional and national government offices, outside counsel, consultants and other regulatory bodies.  Meaning that several key stakeholders must be managed to their satisfaction.  Importantly, the legal Advisor will very often have to manage work flow peaks and valleys, and competing internal departmental interests.  Consequently the Office Holder must have relevant and timely information and data to make informed decisions while focusing on mitigating risks on behalf of the county government and the Governor.



In addition, County Governments (Taita Taveta included) are ramping up their investments in initiatives surrounding governance, risk management, internal auditing and compliance due to the changing landscape of regulatory issues worldwide.  Such initiatives will require sound legal systems to easily help the County Government navigate the risks while growing investments and revenue in general.

One challenge I have faced since taking over has been a jumbled filing system (as there was no official handover) and lack of support staff.  On the positive, we now have an alphabetical filing system, have done seven billsand five policies with individual departments at my own initiative, in addition to handling a myriad of court matters and advisories to various departments. I have since sought support in particular the hiring of two junior counsels, a court clerk and research assistant which will go a long way in ensuring:-

  • We reduce the number of pending cases against the County Government
  • Improve on research thus have more plausible opinions and court pleadings
  • We reduce the costs incurred on the head of legal fees as instead of hiring external lawyers on all matters, the department can/shall make use of available internal counsel to handle certain matters at a reduced cost
  • There is continuous Professional Development as junior counsel grow in the legal unit in the Governor’s Office and are exposed to trainings and research thus enhancing their capacity
  • Proper distribution of work across the unit geared at improved output and target realization
  • All legal related issues are handled on time thus nothing is left to chance
  • Proper re-organization resulting in overall efficiency and institutionalization of meritocracy compliance and audit across other departments.
  1. PENDING OUTSTANDINGLEGAL FEES TODATE

On assumption of office, the previous records retrieved on cases from 2013-2017 for legal fees and claims due were as hereunder:-

(i)       Ngaira & Co. Advocates

Ksh. 6 million – the bills incorporate debts inherited from the defunct local entities i.e. Taveta Town Council before inception of devolution and after

(ii)      Jadi & Co. Advocates

Ksh. 4.2 million – the pending bills also include legal debts inherited from the defunct Municipal Council of Voi dated back to 2013

(iii)     M/s Shariff & Co. Advocates

Kshs. 3.7 million – the bills are as a result of the case the firm appealed on behalf of the County Government of Taita Taveta after and before devolution

(iv)     Mr. Festus Mwakera – Kshs. 1,943,984.00 – in relation to a case No. 2/2010; judgement passed on 11 May 2010 in favour of the plaintiff

(v)      Munyao Muthama and Kasundi Advocate – Kshs. 5,916,000.00

(vi)     John Bwire and Co. Advocates – Kshs. 6,445,530.00

(vii)    Njiru Boniface and Co. Advocates on behalf of Mr. Mwangemi c/o Mwangemi General Contractors – Kshs. 16,256,293.75

(viii)   Juma Nyaga and Company Advocates:–

Kshs. 3,500,000.00

Kshs. 3,675,000.00

Kshs. 3,858,750.00

(ix)     SRMCC No. 29 of 2012 – M.K. Mulei and Co. Advocates – Kshs. 896,043.00.00

On behalf of Mumma Muthembi

(x)      MSC ELRC 542/2017

Benedict Mtoto versus County Government

Munyao Muthama and Kashindi Advocates

Kshs. 1,624,896.00

This amounted to Kshs. 58,016,496.75.



Upon scrutiny of documentation and court documents filed, the outstanding due figures to external lawyers are as hereunder (figures which includes sums inherited from the previous regime):-

(i)       Ngaira & Co. Advocates

Ksh. 6 million – the bills incorporate debts inherited from the defunct local entities i.e. Taveta Town Council before inception of devolution and after

(ii)      Jadi & Co. Advocates

Ksh. 4.2 million – the pending bills also include legal debts inherited from the defunct Municipal Council of Voi dated back to 2013

(iii)     M/s Shariff & Co. Advocates

Kshs. 3.7 million – the bills are as a result of the case the firm appealed on behalf of the County Government of Taita Taveta after and before devolution

(iv)     Mr. Festus Mwakera – Kshs. 1,943,984.00 – in relation to a case No. 2/2010; judgement passed on 11 May 2010 in favour of the plaintiff

(v)      Munyao Muthama and Kasundi Advocate – Kshs. 5,916,000.00

(vi)     John Bwire and Co. Advocates – Kshs. 6,445,530.00

(vii)    Juma Nyaga and Company Advocates:–

Kshs. 3,500,000.00

Referring to a letter from Juma Nyaga and Co. Advocates dated 5/2/2018

(viii)   SRMCC No. 29 of 2012 – M.K. Mulei and Co. Advocates – Kshs. 896,043.00.00

On behalf of Mumma Muthembi

Thus the total possible claims amount to Kshs. 32, 301, 557.00. Once instructions are issued to the pre-qualified advocates, legal fees accrues, it is not money paid to the legal Advisor but monies due to advocates for legal services rendered. In addition, a contract for legal service provision is enough proof to warrant execution proceedings against the County Government in the event of non-payment. Such execution includes;-

Attachment of County Government properties and sale via public auction for recovery of the raised fee notes and interests thereon, exposing the County Government to further financial risks. Allow me to clarify that even the proposed allocation of Kshs. 26 million in the 2019/2020 estimates was only to cover the highlighted pending fee notes and not for any administrative costs etc.

In the 2018/2019 approved estimates, the legal services provisions under the Governor’s office were Kshs. 3 million, the supplementary budget(2018/2019) took cognisance of the shortfall in allocation by adding 5M to legal services in the office of the Governor and then moved to create a County Legal Services vote to Carter for all departments and set aside 10M.This was due to the fact that there was not only  increased public interest litigation but other active matters that were ongoing.It is no secret that legal fees in this Country is exorbitant and compared to other Counties,Taita Taveta County has managed to expend considerably lower sums on the same.

It is also worth highlighting that the 2019/2020 estimates had a proposed provision for 26M as County Legal Fees.

  1. CASES HANDLED

Below are court cases which I have handled and even appeared on behalf of the County Government to date.

 

 

CASE NO

 

PARTIES

 

CASE ACTION

 

CASE OUTCOME

 

CURRERNT STATUS

MSA PETITION NO. 21 OF 2018 County Government of Taita-Taveta

=Vs= Cabinet Secretary, Ministry of Land & Another

–          The County Government petitioned the Court to suspend the operation of Regulations 12 and 27 of the Community Lands Regulations, 2017 which provided that the National Government shall take up the role of preparing an inventory and registration of all unregistered community land, should the County Government fail to carry out this exercise within 12 months from the date of commencement of the Regulations. –          The County successfully managed to obtain suspension of the said regulations for six (6) months, through an Order issued by the Court on 4th June, 2019

–          The Court also ordered that the Council of Governors be enjoined in the Petition.

 

–          The case has been scheduled for hearing on 15th October, 2019.
MSA ELRC NO 897 OF 2018 Lucas Leeroy & 24 Others =Vs= County Government of Taita-Taveta & Another

 

–          The Chief Officers had sued the County Government for the conversion of their terms of service to permanent and pensionable.

–          They also sought for the extension of their terms of service in place of competitive recruitment process as provided for in law.

 

–          The County Government in a court Order issued on 11th Februe2ary, 2019 successfully managed to protect its interest by having the said suit dismissed in its entirety for reasons that the Court lacked jurisdiction to hear the suit. –          Suit dismissed in favour of the County Government, court file closed.
VOI JR NO. 18 OF 2018

&

VOI MISC. APPLICATION NO. 19 OF 2018

Jacinta Wanjiku & 2 Other =V= County Govt of Taita Taveta

Isabella Kemunto Sato & Others =V= County Govt of Taita Taveta

 

–          The two suits were filed against the County Government seeking to quash the entire County Government of Taita Taveta Finance Act, 2018 for allegedly failing to adhere to the requirement of public participation and increasing market fees without involving the residents. –          The two suit were dismissed in favour of the County Government through and Order dated 14th February,  2019 –          Suits dismissed in favour of the County Government, court files closed.
MSA ELRC NO. 11 OF 2019 Jacob Mwakugu & 12 Others =V= County Govet of Taita Taveta & Another –          Following dismissal of the ELRC No. 897 of 2018, the Chief Officers instituted another suit seeking for the same Orders they had sought; conversion of their terms of employment to permanent and pensionable.



–          They also sought for reinstatement into their positions as chief officers.

 

–          The County Government defended its position as in the previous suit but the Court ruled that since the Claimants had filed an Appeal before the Public Service Commission, it had jurisdiction to hear the suit. –          Through a court Order dated 21st March, 2019 directed the parties to resolve the dispute before the Public Service Commission within 30 days, issued a temporary injunction against the County from advertising the positions for or recruiting new chief officers.

–          The County Appealed against this decision to the Court of Appeal.

MSA APPEAL NO. 18 OF 2019 County Government of Taita Taveta & Anor =V= Jacob Mwakugu & 12 others –          The County Government appealed against the decision of the Industrial Court in ELRC No. 11 of 2019 wherein it sought to stay the proceedings before the employment and labour court, and to have the orders barring the County from advertising and recruiting the chief officers set aside. –          Through an Order dated 6th may, 2019 the Court of Appeal ruled in favour of the County Government by staying the proceedings before the superior court and setting aside the previous Orders. –          The Court of Appeal ruled in favour of the County Government.

–          The matter is pending before the Court of Appeal for hearing.

MSA SPMCC NO. 52 OF 2014

 

Erick Mwaura Thuku =V= Taita Taveta County

 

–          A suit seeking to commit the County Secretary to civil jail for allegedly contempt of court for failing to pay for the decretal sum arising from the judgement delivered on the 11th of May, 2016. –          The Application seeking to commit the County Secretary to Civil jail for alleged contempt of court was dismissed via a court order dated 3rd September, 2018. –          Ruling delivered in favour of the County Government.

–          Court file closed.

MSA ELRC NO. 542 OF 2016 –          Benedict Mwabili Mtoto =V= County Government & Anor –          An Application for Notice to show cause against the County Government and the Public Service Board, following a judgment entered against the County on 22nd February, 2018 where the Claimant was entitled to Kshs. 1, 392, 496 –          The Application was dismissed with costs to the County Government, in a Ruling dated 19th March, 2019 –          Ruling delivered in favour of the County Government.
VOI CONST PET. NO. 15 OF 2017 Murithi Robert & 17 Others =V= County Government of Taita Taveta & Anor –      A petition seeking for a permanent injunction against the County Government from arresting the petitioners and confiscating the petitioners’ gaming and betting machines. –          The matter is ongoing in court.

–          The Petitioners are yet to serve the County Government’s Counsel with their written submissions before the ruling date is set.

–          Matter pending before the Court.
VOI SPMCC NO. 3 OF 2019 Mercy Mwamburi =V= Danson M. Mabruki, County Govt of Taita-Taveta & Others –      A land case against the County Govt and others, in respect of Residential Plot No. 11 Voi, now known as LR No. 1956/1863-Voi.

–      Suit seeking amongst others, a mandatory injunction directed at the County Government and the Commissioner for lands to remove the names of the 1st and 2nd Defendants from the land records in respect of the said parcel

–       Counsels for the County Government have proceeded to file a replying affidavit to the Plaintiff’s Application dated 18th May, 2019 seeking for investigation and forensic reports on the letters of allotment and all other documents issued in respect of the property by or under instructions of the County Government. –       Matter pending hearing of the Application before the court.
MSA ELRC JR NO. 1 OF 2018 Hon. Gapser Kabaka & Anor =V= County Govet of Taita-Taveta & Others –      Judicial Review against the County Government seeking to quash the decision of the County Government sending the Applicants; managing and Finance Directors of Tavevo to compulsory leave, having been implicated in the mismanagement and pilferage of public funds at Tavevo. –       The County Government’s counsels took up the matter and have since filed the replying affidavit including submission to the substantive Application. –       The matter is pending ruling before the Court.
VOI SPMCC NO. 189 OF 2018 Gladys Pwaru Maiza =V= County Government of Taita-Taveta –          Suit against the County Government for a claim of Kshs. 132, 390 in specific damages including general damages over an accident involving the County Government’s motor vehicle 06 CG 031A which allegedly occurred on 14th August, 2017 along St. Barnabas Church Road –          Counsels for the County Government have since taken up the matter and filed a statement of defence.

–          They have also written to Madison Insurance Company Ltd, the County’s insurer to take up the matter on behalf of the County.

–          The County’s insurer has taken up the matter and have sought supporting documents to the case, with a view of settling the claim
NRBI PETITION NO. 281 OF 2019 Kenya Wildlife Service =V= County Government of Taita Taveta –          Suit seeking equitable sharing of the revenue from Tsavo East and West , specifically the development of a mechanism for the benefit sharing as provided for under the Wildlife (Conservation and Management) Act, Cap 376 Laws of Kenya –          Matter certified urgent

–          Matter listed for directions on 26th September, 2019

–          Matter awaiting directions on 26th September, 2019
VOI CONST. PETITION NO. 14 OF 2019 Mohamed Bishar & 3 Others =V= County Government of Taita taveta & Others –          The Applicants sought to stop the County Government from flushing out the illegal Carmel herders from Ranches within the County. –          Matter proceeded for hearing and through an Order dated 27th June, 2019 the Honourable Court ruled in favour of the County Government by allowing it to continue with the eviction exercise as its legal and legitimate function. –          Matter held in abeyance

 

CHAHILU EDWIN

LEGAL ADVISOR.

more recommended stories