Categories: *Featured News

SOME MYSTERIOUS HAPPENINGS AROUND THE TAITA TAVETA COUNTY CLERK, ON CONTRACTS ALLOCATION

 

Taita Taveta Couty residents are concerned by some revelations surrounding project implementation and the tricks used to ensure individuals make away with funds budgeted for development projects.

This comes at a time when the County Government disclosed that it had paid all pending bills totalling to Sh414 million. The pending bills are said to have originated from projects budgeted and approved by former administration between 2013 to 2017.

Immediately after Governor Granton Samboja was sworn in after toppling John Mruttu, he embarked on an investigative process aimed at finding out how the outgoing government conducted itself on matters project implementation and service delivery.

The move was well received by Taita Taveta county residents.

To this respect, Governor Samboja formed a taskforce committee chaired by his then Personal Assistant, Mr Philemon Mwaisaka. The Mwaisaka led committee presented its report to the governor on February 5, 2018.

 

Task Force Committee

The report had detailed findings and recommendations on each project in the county. It was upon the County Government to take necessary action as recommended by the taskforce committee to ensure the stalled project would be revived and completed.

Below are details of selected projects as reported in the taskforce report.

******

MRUGHUA SOCIAL HALL IN BURA WARD

According to the Mwaisaka led taskforce report on project verification 2013 – 2017:

Budget amount: Sh2,000,000

Contracted amount: Sh3,999,877

Certified & paid amount: Nil

Pending bills:Nil

Mrughua Social Hall as reported in the Task Force Report.

OBSERVATIONS

1. Building materials were dumped on site.

2. The site is abandoned.

RECOMMENDATIONS

1. The County Department of Trade and Community Affairs should fasttrack the commencement of the project implementation.

2. Due process should be done with a view of terminating the contract.

Up to date a concrete foundation stands as the only sign of a social hall.

Stalled Mrughua Social Hall as it is currently

Questions:

1. Where are the Sh2,000,000 budgeted for the project?

2. What does contracted amount of Sh3,999,877 mean. Did the foundation cost that much?

3. With nil pending bills, does it mean the contractor was fully paid?

4. Who has the answers?

******

MWANGONI SOCIA HALL – SAGALLA WARD

According to the Mwaisaka led taskforce report on Taita Taveta County projects verification 2013 – 2017:

Department – Trade

Financial Year – 2016/2017

Contractor: Capital Mvono Contractors

Budgeted Amount: Sh2,000,000

Contracted amount: Sh1,972,000

Certified & paid amount: Nil

Pending bills: Sh1,972,000

SCOPE OF WORKS: Construction of a social hall

 

Mwongoni Social Hall as extractwd from the Task Force Report

OBSERVATIONS

i. There was poor workmanship as evidenced by the huge cracks seen on the walls and foundation.

ii. The building has stalled at ring beam level.

FINDINGS

i. The project was started without a project management committee.

ii. There was no technical supervision.

iii. There was lack of proper coordination between departments, local administration and other stakeholders.

iv. The structure has failed before completion.

v. The facility has no toilet and tank.

RECOMMENDATIONS

i. There is need to vet and blacklist contractors with a history of poor quality works.

ii. Detailed technical evaluation of the project should be conducted preferably by a structural engineer to establish durability and safety of use (it can either be salvaged or condemned).

iii. Proper planning is required in packaging the social hall projects to cater for all the necessary components such as toilet, parking, fence, electricity and water supply.

Mwangoni Social Hall current state. Some walls have so far fallen off.

QUESTIONS

1. Where are the Sh2,000,000 as budgeted for in the project?

2. Does the Sh1,972,000 pending bills make part of the already paid up Sh414,000,000?

3. Why did the project stall?

4. Why hasn’t the project been revived and completed?

5. If this contractor did such a shoddy job, why has he been awarded a fresh contract to grade a road in the same ward?

*****

WUNDANYI MBALE WARD

CONSTRUCTION OF SHIGHARO DISPENSARY

According to the Mwaisaka led taskforce report on Taita Taveta County projects verification 2013 – 2017:

Department: Health Services

Financial Year: 2013/2014, 2014/2015 and 2015/2016

Contractor: Kawthar Investment Ltd & Saghala Company Ltd

Budget Amount: Sh1,000,000 + Sh8,280,000 for Kawthar Investment Ltd and Sh5,000,000 for Saghala Co. Ltd.

Contracted amount: Sh9,542,936 for Kawthar & Sh5,068,423 for Saghala Co Ltd.

Certified & paid: Sh4,999,417 for Kawthar (not paid) & Sh1, 078,974 for Saghala Co Ltd (certified but not paid).

Pending bills: Sh4,999,417 for Kawthar Inv. & Ksh1,078,974 for Saghala Co. Ltd.

 

Shigharo Dispensary Project as extracted from the Task Force Report

SCOPE OF WORKS: Construction of a dispensary

OBSERVATIONS

i. The project has stalled.

ii. The workmanship was satisfactory.

iii. The superstructure is complete up to roofing; septic tank, doors and window frame fixed and room plastered.

iv. The facility does not have an established access road.

FINDINGS

i. A second contractor was given the work to complete the dispensary.

ii. Both contractors delayed/abandoned the site because of delayed payments.

iii. The facility does not have the prerequisite components of a health facility like placenta pit, incinerator and perimeter fence.

RECOMMENDATIONS

i. The County Government should fasttrack the completion of the project in order to realize its objective.

ii. The County Government should provide funds for the prerequisite components like access road, incinerator, placenta pit and perimeter fence.

iii. There is need to review the policy that guides payments of construction work.

Shigharo Dispensary current state.

QUESTIONS

1. Has the project been completed?

2. Are the pending bills part of the Sh414 million paid up by the County Government?

3. Has the County Government provided funds for access road, an incenarator, placenta pit and perimeter fence as recommended by the taskforce committee?

4. If the pending bills have so far been fully paid and the project is still incomplete, who authorised payment? Why?

*****

TAVETA SUB COUNTY

MATA WARD

According the the Mwaisaka led taskforce report on project verification 2013 – 2017:

Project Name: Musyoka road

Road: 13 Km

DEPARTMENT: Public Works

Financial Year: 2015-2016

Contractor: Msuya General Supplies

Budget amount: Sh5,000,000

Contracted amount: Sh4,969,728

Certified & paid: Sh4,969,728

Pending bills: Nil

 

Musyoka Road Project as extracted from the Task Force Report

SCOPE OF WORKS: Erection and casing of 12 lines of culverts and gravel 1457m3 for 1.5KM

OBSERVATIONS

i. The project was not completed.

ii. The culverts are poorly done and exposed with no backfill.

iii. Several culverts were broken.

iv. The culverts were an impediment to flow of traffic.

v. There was no public participation at any moment during implementation.

vi. There was very poor technical supervision.

FINDINGS

i. Relevant Technical Departments were not involved in the project implementation.

ii. There was lack of coordination between departments i.e. Ward Administrator was not involved.

iii. The work was certified and the contractor paid in full despite the works being incomplete.

iv. There was no value for money.

RECOMMENDATIONS

i. The County Government should develop project management policy and procedures.

ii. Special audit of the entire project should be undertaken.

iii. The contractor should be compelled to redo the works as per the bills of quantities or be blacklisted.

iv. The County Government should involve all stakeholders in project planning, implementation and monitoring.

v. Enhance project coordination and integration during project implementation among stakeholders.

vi. Technical staff should execute their mandate free from political interferences during project implementation.

QUESTIONS

1. Is there value for money in this project? Who authorized full payments under the status?

2. If Ward Administrators were not involved as stated, who was supervising the project?

3. What benefit have Mata residents received from this taskforce report on this project? After findings, what did the relevant authorities do to ensure the completion of the project?

4. What have they done to ensure technical staff execute their mandate free from political interference during projects implementation?

5.When will the project be completed?

******

Despite the recommendations, some projects are still stalled yet all the pending bills have been paid.

The county government has currently been tasked by residents to produce a report listing all pending bills paid, each with the corresponding project implemented to enable countizens to audit them.

There has been hot debates in some social groups in the county where some strange details are cropping up.

It is claimed that a section of County Assembly officials are highly involved in dubious deals making residents lose value for the money invested in the devolved unit in terms of development.

There are claims that County Assembly Clerk, Mr Gadiel Maghanga, has more that 10 companies registered under his names and or his accomplices. The allegations indicate that the companies have been winning most contracts advertised by the county government since the inception of devolution.

Being one of the senior officers at the assembly, it is alleged that he uses his office to influence tenders in the county. Though some residents do not really care who is awarded tenders or contracts, they are however concerned about poor workmanship by some of his companies as reported in the taskforce report.

Some of the said companies he owns include:

1. Gejesh General Ltd

2. Gajesh enterprises Ltd

3. Mwabolo construction

4. Kigzwell Ltd

5. GM Contractors Ltd

6. Pearless general hardware and supplies

7. Joyrass enterprises Ltd among others.

It is reported that Gajesh General Ltd is currently constructing the assembly offices, a four-storey building which has been under construction since 2017. The building is still less than 60% complete.

It is further alleged that in the financial year 2018/2019, Gajesh won a contract to construct Bomeni social hall in Bomeni ward in Taveta which stalled at foundation and slab level.

Taita Taveta residents hope that relevant authorities will pick up this matter to ensure that locals benefit from the budgeted projects as proposed in the CIDP for them to get value for money.

Mwachere Shuma

Leave a Comment

View Comments

Share
Published by
Mwachere Shuma

Recent Posts

TAITA TAVETA: SEVEN DAYS HAVE ELAPSED — HAS SENATOR KAJWANG SENT WAKUJAA’S GOVERNMENT FILES TO EACC?

  By Kwaela News Network (KNN) | Governance & Accountability The seven-day ultimatum issued to…

18 hours ago

THE ERA OF POLITICAL EUPHORIA IN TAITA TAVETA COUNTY IS OVER

  The days when political party waves and symbolism single-handedly determined election outcomes in Taita-Taveta…

1 day ago

TAITA TAVETA: CAN THE DCI CRACK THE NUT? DORCAS MLGHU’S PUBLIC OUTBURST PUTS COUNTY EXECUTIVE UNDER FRESH PRESSURE

  The growing controversy surrounding the financial management of Taita Taveta County has taken another…

2 days ago

THE GOVERNOR DISCOVERS FISCAL DISCIPLINE — FOUR YEARS TOO LATE?

  Perhaps one of the most ironic moments of Governor Andrew Mwadime's appearance before the…

3 days ago

NDARA B LAND DISPUTE: 63 RESIDENTS SERVED WITH THREE-MONTH EVICTION NOTICE FOLLOWING COURT RULING

Affected families in Mlambenyi, Golani and Mto Mwagodi face a February 2027 deadline as the…

3 days ago

THE WRONG TIME: GOVERNOR WAKUJAA’S DEFENCE

During a Senate Public Finance Committee meeting, Taita Taveta Governor Andrew Mwadime, popularly known as…

6 days ago