Categories: *Featured News

COVID-19 FUNDS IN TAITA TAVETA: YEARS AFTER THE AUDIT, WHO ANSWERED THE QUESTIONS — AND WHO WAS HELD ACCOUNTABLE?

As High Court reduces Rodger Ngoo’s defamation damages from KSh 12 million to KSh 4 million, crucial questions about the investigation, accountability and recovery of public funds remain unanswered.

When the COVID-19 pandemic struck Kenya, public money was mobilised to protect lives, equip health facilities, support healthcare workers and help counties respond to an unprecedented emergency.

In Taita Taveta County, questions subsequently emerged about how some of those funds were spent.

The Office of the Auditor-General examined the county’s COVID-19 expenditure and identified significant concerns involving procurement, accounting and the delivery of medical supplies. The findings were serious enough to prompt recommendations for further investigation.

Yet, years later, an important question remains for the people of Taita Taveta:

What happened after the audit raised those concerns?

Were the issues investigated to their logical conclusion? Were any public officers or suppliers found responsible for irregular expenditure or financial loss? Were any funds recovered? And where can members of the public access the official findings and follow-up reports?

These are questions about public money, institutional accountability and the public’s right to know.

They deserve clear answers.

Read Also: COVID-19 SCANDAL IN TAITA TAVETA COUNTY

1. WHAT DID THE AUDITOR-GENERAL FIND?

In a special audit report on the utilisation of COVID-19 funds by county governments, the Auditor-General examined how public resources were used during the pandemic.

Contemporaneous reporting on the Taita Taveta findings highlighted concerns about procurement procedures, the classification of expenditure and the delivery and acceptance of medical supplies. The Auditor-General recommended further investigation into the county’s COVID-19 expenditure.

STANDARD:Auditor General Calls for Investigations Taita Taveta County Covid Funds

Among the most concerning findings in the Auditor-General’s report on the County Executive of Taita Taveta for the financial year ended 30 June 2020 was the procurement of medical equipment and supplies.

According to the audit, a vendor had been contracted to supply medical equipment and supplies valued at approximately KSh 42.88 million. The report stated that supplies worth approximately KSh 13 million had been delivered, while the Inspection and Acceptance Committee accepted supplies worth only KSh 9 million.

The Auditor-General concluded that there was no value for money in respect of KSh 33,882,950 spent on undelivered and rejected medical supplies.

REPORT OF THE AUDITOR-GENERAL ON COUNTY EXECUTIVE OF TAITA/TAVETA COUNTY

That is a substantial amount of public money.

However, an important distinction must be made: an audit finding of expenditure on undelivered or rejected supplies does not, by itself, establish that the entire amount was stolen or that a particular individual committed a criminal offence.

It does establish that serious questions needed answers.

Who authorised the procurement? What goods were ordered? What was actually delivered? Why were some supplies not accepted? Were payments made for goods that the county never received or could not use? What steps were taken to recover any money improperly paid?

The public deserves to know whether those questions were subsequently resolved.

The same audit report also questioned an unexplained transfer of approximately KSh 1.3 million between county bank accounts, stating that the occurrence and validity of the transaction could not be confirmed because it was not adequately explained or supported.

REPORT OF THE AUDITOR-GENERAL ON COUNTY EXECUTIVE OF TAITA/TAVETA FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE, 2020

These findings should not be treated as proof of criminal guilt. But neither should they disappear from public discussion simply because years have passed.

2. WHAT HAPPENED TO THE AUDITOR-GENERAL’S RECOMMENDATIONS?

An audit report is not the end of an accountability process.

Where an audit identifies questionable expenditure, weaknesses in procurement or possible financial loss, the next steps are crucial. Depending on the nature of the findings, those steps may include obtaining explanations from accounting officers, reconciling payments and deliveries, recovering money, taking administrative action or referring suspected criminal conduct to the relevant investigative authorities.

In April 2021, The Standard reported that the Auditor-General had recommended an investigation into Taita Taveta County’s COVID-19 expenditure following the identification of anomalies and procurement concerns. 

But the central question today is not simply what the audit found in 2020.

It is what happened afterwards.

Kwaela News Network is seeking clarification on the following matters:

  • Did the Auditor-General receive formal responses from the County Government addressing each of the material findings?
  • Did the Auditor-General or the relevant audit teams undertake follow-up work to establish whether the issues had been resolved?
  • Were explanations, invoices, delivery records, inspection reports and payment vouchers subsequently provided?
  • Were the recommendations implemented, rejected or left outstanding?
  • Was any financial loss quantified and formally confirmed after further examination?
  • If losses were confirmed, were recovery proceedings initiated?
  • Is there a follow-up report, management letter, audit committee report or other official document showing the outcome?

The Auditor-General’s special audit reports are publicly listed on the Office’s official website. However, the existence of the original report alone does not establish what happened to every recommendation afterwards.

The public needs an account of the follow-up, not merely a reminder that an audit once took place.

3. DID EACC OR DCI INVESTIGATE THE ALLEGATIONS?

The Ethics and Anti-Corruption Commission (EACC) and the Directorate of Criminal Investigations (DCI) are among the institutions that may be relevant where allegations of corruption, fraud or other criminal conduct arise.

Kwaela News Network has not located a publicly accessible EACC or DCI report that conclusively establishes the outcome of an investigation into the specific Taita Taveta COVID-19 expenditure concerns discussed in this article.

That does not prove that no investigation took place. An investigation may have been conducted without its full details being published, and an absence of publicly accessible information is not evidence of either guilt or innocence.

Nevertheless, the lack of an identifiable public outcome raises legitimate questions.

Questions to the EACC:

  1. Did the Commission receive a complaint or referral concerning the use of COVID-19 funds by Taita Taveta County?
  2. If so, when was the complaint received, and what was its reference number?
  3. Was an investigation opened?
  4. Were any county officials, suppliers or other persons interviewed or required to provide documents?
  5. Were the allegations substantiated, partly substantiated or found unsupported?
  6. Was any file forwarded to the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions?
  7. Were any recovery proceedings or other remedial measures recommended?
  8. If the matter was closed, what was the basis for closure, to the extent that the information may lawfully be disclosed?

Questions to the DCI:

  1. Did the Directorate investigate the specific allegations concerning COVID-19 expenditure in Taita Taveta?
  2. Were any alleged procurement irregularities referred for criminal investigation?
  3. Were statements taken, records obtained or forensic examinations undertaken?
  4. Was a file submitted to the prosecution authorities?
  5. If the investigation did not proceed, was it because the allegations were unsupported, the evidence was insufficient, or for another reason that can lawfully be disclosed?

These are requests for clarification, not allegations that either institution failed to act.

If investigations were conducted and the matter was properly resolved, the public deserves an appropriate explanation. If investigations remain pending, the public deserves to know their status to the extent permitted by law.

If no investigation was undertaken, the relevant authorities should explain why, particularly where the audit identified concerns that warranted further scrutiny.

4. WERE ANY OFFICERS OR SUPPLIERS HELD RESPONSIBLE?

This is perhaps the most important accountability question.

If the audit identified expenditure on undelivered or rejected supplies, what happened to the people and entities involved in the procurement, inspection, approval and payment processes?

Were the relevant officers required to account for their decisions?

Were suppliers required to deliver outstanding goods, refund payments or otherwise remedy any breach of contract?

Were disciplinary measures taken where warranted?

Were any civil recovery proceedings commenced?

Were any criminal charges filed? If charges were filed, what was the outcome?

And if the investigations established that the expenditure was properly authorised and accounted for, where is the documentation explaining that conclusion?

It is important not to assume that every audit irregularity amounts to corruption. Public officers and suppliers are entitled to due process, and responsibility must be established on the available evidence.

But accountability also requires that concerns raised by an independent audit receive a documented response.

An unresolved audit question is not proof of theft. Equally, an unresolved question should not be mistaken for proof that everything was in order.

The public should not be left to choose between unproven allegations and unverified assurances.

Read Also: TAITA TAVETA: MORE HIGHLIGHTS ON UTILIZATION OF COVID FUNDS

5. HAVE ANY LOST PUBLIC FUNDS BEEN RECOVERED?

Where a financial loss is established, identifying the loss is only part of the process. Authorities must also consider whether the money can be recovered and whether those responsible should face appropriate consequences.

Kwaela News Network is therefore asking the County Government, the Auditor-General and the relevant investigative agencies to clarify:

  • Was any financial loss arising from the COVID-19 expenditure formally established?
  • If so, what was the confirmed amount?
  • How much, if any, has been recovered?
  • Were refunds, replacement supplies, insurance claims or other recovery mechanisms pursued?
  • Were any outstanding amounts referred for civil recovery?
  • If no recovery was pursued, why not?
  • If the disputed expenditure was eventually justified, what evidence supports that conclusion?

These questions matter because public money belongs to the people.

Whether the issue concerns KSh 1 million, KSh 10 million or tens of millions of shillings, taxpayers deserve to know how their money was used and what happened when questions arose.

Read Also: HUGE COVID RIP-OFFS LAND GOVERNOR ON EACC RADAR

6. THE COUNTY ASSEMBLY’S INQUIRY: WHERE IS THE FINAL ACCOUNT?

The controversy also attracted attention from the Taita Taveta County Assembly.

Contemporaneous reporting in July 2020 indicated that the Assembly’s Health and Sanitation Committee was examining concerns surrounding COVID-19 expenditure. In April 2021, The Star reported comments from the committee’s chair indicating that he did not believe funds had been misappropriated and that payments had gone to the intended beneficiaries. (The Star)

Those comments are relevant and should not be ignored.

But they raise further questions about the formal record of the Assembly’s work.

Did the committee produce a final report? Was that report tabled and adopted by the Assembly? What evidence did it examine? Did it address the Auditor-General’s specific findings about medical supplies, procurement procedures and unsupported expenditure? Did it recommend any corrective action or referral to investigative agencies?

Most importantly, is there a final report that the public can read?

Kwaela News Network has not independently established the full contents and final disposition of the Assembly committee’s inquiry from the material located for this article.

The Assembly should therefore publish or identify its final report, relevant minutes, resolutions and follow-up correspondence, subject to applicable legal restrictions.

If the committee concluded that the funds were properly accounted for, the public should be able to examine the evidence and understand how that conclusion addressed the Auditor-General’s findings.

If the committee identified matters requiring further investigation, the public should know whether those recommendations were implemented.

The purpose is not to dismiss the Assembly’s work. It is to establish what the work achieved.

7. THE RODGER NGOO CASE: A DEFAMATION JUDGMENT IS NOT A FORENSIC AUDIT

The public debate surrounding the COVID-19 allegations has acquired another dimension through the legal proceedings involving Rodger Ngoo.

On 8 October 2026, the High Court at Voi delivered judgment in Ngoo v Mwakima & another, Civil Appeal No. E065 of 2025, under the reported citation [2026] KEHC 15401 (KLR). (SheriaNet)

The appeal arose from a defamation case. The dispute concerned publications about alleged misuse of COVID-19 funds and whether those publications exposed the defendants to liability under the law of defamation.

According to the judgment details previously reported in connection with the case, the original award of KSh 12 million in general damages was reduced to KSh 4 million.

That is a substantial reduction. But KSh 4 million remains a considerable liability for an individual, particularly a young person who may not have the financial resources of a large media organisation or a wealthy litigant.

The distinction is essential: a court deciding a defamation case is not necessarily conducting a forensic audit of county expenditure.

A defamation case examines the publication complained of, whether it was defamatory, what defences were available and whether the legal requirements for liability were met. It does not automatically resolve every underlying question about the public expenditure discussed in the publication.

Consequently, the defamation ruling should not be presented as proof that COVID-19 funds were stolen. Nor should the reduction of damages be presented as proof that the underlying concerns were fabricated.

Those questions require their own evidence and, where appropriate, investigation by the competent authorities.

This distinction is particularly important for public-interest journalism.

A person may raise a genuine public concern but express it in language that creates legal exposure. Equally, a person who believes a publication is defamatory is entitled to seek a legal remedy. Neither proposition removes the public’s right to ask what happened to the money.

8. DID THE REDUCTION FROM KSh 12 MILLION TO KSh 4 MILLION END THE MATTER?

The High Court’s reduction of the damages is significant. However, it does not automatically mean that the entire award has been cancelled or that no further legal steps are possible.

The actual orders in the judgment, including any directions concerning interest, costs, injunctions and enforcement, must be read carefully. Any further challenge or application would depend on the applicable law and procedural requirements.

Kwaela News Network is not asking the court to disregard the law because the underlying issue is politically or publicly sensitive.

Rather, we believe that two questions must be considered separately:

First: Was the publication legally defamatory, and what remedy was justified under the law?

Second: What happened to the COVID-19 expenditure that gave rise to the public controversy in the first place?

The first question belongs in the judicial process. The second demands a clear, documented account from the institutions responsible for auditing, investigating and overseeing public expenditure.

Neither question should be used to silence the other.

9. SHOULD A YOUNG JOURNALIST’S FUTURE BE DESTROYED BY A MULTIMILLION-SHILLING LIABILITY?

This case also raises a wider question about the consequences of substantial defamation awards.

Rodger Ngoo is entitled to the same protection of the law as any other person. If a court finds that he is liable for defamation, that decision must be respected unless it is lawfully varied or set aside.

At the same time, a financial award of several million shillings can have consequences far beyond the immediate dispute. For a young person without substantial financial resources, it may affect employment, livelihood, family responsibilities and the ability to continue participating in public debate.

That is why proportionality in defamation remedies matters.

The purpose of damages is not to make a successful claimant’s remedy meaningless. Nor should public-interest reporting become a licence to publish unverified accusations as established facts.

The challenge is to uphold both principles: protecting people against defamatory publications while preserving a meaningful space for responsible journalism, scrutiny of public institutions and good-faith questions about public money.

The reduction from KSh 12 million to KSh 4 million invites public discussion about the appropriate scale of damages in the circumstances of the case. But whether that amount should be reduced further, or whether the award should be set aside, is a legal question that must be determined through the proper process and on the actual evidence.

It would be unfair to suggest that a person’s good intentions automatically excuse defamatory wording. It would be equally unhelpful to treat a defamation judgment as a substitute for investigating the public expenditure that prompted the controversy.

The public should be able to demand accountability without assuming that every allegation is true—and without assuming that every person who raises a concern is acting in bad faith.

10. IS THE JUDICIARY DEFENDING SUSPECTED MISAPPROPRIATORS?

This is a question that requires particular care.

A reduction in damages in a defamation appeal does not, by itself, establish that the Judiciary is protecting suspected offenders. Courts must decide the disputes brought before them under the law and on the evidence presented.

There is also no basis, from the audit findings alone, to declare that any particular person committed a crime. That requires an appropriate investigation and, where a prosecution follows, determination through due process.

But asking whether the institutions responsible for investigating the underlying financial concerns acted on the audit is entirely legitimate.

If the Auditor-General identified serious procurement and accounting issues, the public should be able to establish whether those issues were resolved.

If the EACC or DCI investigated, the public should be told the outcome to the extent permitted by law.

If the County Assembly conducted an inquiry, its final report should be accessible.

If money was lost, the public should know whether recovery was pursued.

And if the disputed expenditure was ultimately found to be properly accounted for, the authorities should explain how the evidence resolved the questions raised.

The answer to these questions cannot be inferred from the outcome of a separate defamation case.

The appropriate demand is not that the courts abandon the law. It is that every institution discharge its own responsibility, and that the public be given a clear account of what was established.

11. KWAELA NEWS NETWORK’S QUESTIONS TO THE RELEVANT AUTHORITIES

In the interest of public accountability, Kwaela News Network invites the following institutions to provide documented responses.

To the Office of the Auditor-General

  1. What was the final status of the material findings in the audit of Taita Taveta County’s COVID-19 expenditure?
  2. Did the County Government provide satisfactory explanations and supporting documents?
  3. Were any findings resolved, and if so, on what basis?
  4. Were any confirmed financial losses established?
  5. Were recommendations for investigation or recovery followed up?
  6. Is there a subsequent report or official correspondence recording the outcome?

To the Ethics and Anti-Corruption Commission

  1. Did EACC receive or investigate allegations concerning the specific COVID-19 expenditure issues identified in Taita Taveta?
  2. If an investigation took place, what was its outcome?
  3. Were any files referred for prosecution or recovery?
  4. If the matter was closed, can the Commission provide an appropriate explanation of the closure?

To the Directorate of Criminal Investigations

  1. Did DCI investigate the relevant allegations?
  2. Were any suspected offences established or referred to the prosecution authorities?
  3. Is any investigation pending?
  4. If no investigation took place, was a referral ever received, and what can lawfully be disclosed about its disposition?

To the Taita Taveta County Assembly

  1. Where is the final report of the Health and Sanitation Committee’s inquiry into COVID-19 expenditure?
  2. Was the report tabled and adopted?
  3. Did the committee examine the Auditor-General’s specific findings?
  4. What recommendations were made?
  5. What action was taken to implement those recommendations?

To the Taita Taveta County Government

  1. What explanations were provided in response to the Auditor-General’s findings?
  2. Were the disputed medical supplies eventually delivered, accepted, replaced or refunded?
  3. Was any financial loss established?
  4. Were any recovery or disciplinary measures undertaken?
  5. Can the relevant procurement, inspection, payment and recovery records be made available for public scrutiny, subject to applicable law?

To the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions

Where a file was referred for prosecutorial review, what was the outcome? Were charges authorised, further investigations requested, or other action taken?

These questions are directed at obtaining verifiable answers. They are not a declaration that any named person is guilty of wrongdoing.

Kwaela News Network welcomes responses and documentary evidence from all the institutions concerned. Any substantive responses received will be considered fairly and reflected in subsequent reporting.

CONCLUSION: THE PEOPLE OF TAITA TAVETA DESERVE ANSWERS

The COVID-19 pandemic placed enormous pressure on public institutions. It also created an urgent need for transparency because decisions about public money had direct consequences for healthcare workers, patients and communities.

When an independent audit identifies significant concerns about procurement, payments and the delivery of medical supplies, the public has a legitimate interest in knowing what happened next.

Were the concerns resolved? Were any losses established? Were funds recovered? Were any people held accountable? Or was the expenditure eventually explained and accepted?

These questions remain important regardless of the outcome of a defamation case.

The legal proceedings involving Rodger Ngoo must be judged on their own evidence and applicable law. But they should not bring public scrutiny of COVID-19 expenditure to an end.

A journalist who makes an allegation must be prepared to substantiate it. A public officer or supplier facing an allegation is entitled to a fair hearing. And a court must decide the case before it impartially.

At the same time, public institutions have a responsibility to account for public money and to explain the steps taken when an audit raises serious concerns.

The public should not have to choose between responsible journalism and accountability for public funds. Both are essential to a functioning democracy.

If the disputed expenditure was properly accounted for, let the relevant authorities publish the evidence and explain how the audit concerns were resolved.

If financial losses were established, let the public know what was recovered and what action was taken.

If investigations were conducted, let the outcomes be disclosed to the extent permitted by law.

And if the process remains incomplete, the responsible institutions should say so.

Kwaela News Network believes that the people of Taita Taveta deserve more than competing claims, unanswered questions and years of uncertainty.

They deserve a documented account of what happened to their money.

PUBLIC MONEY. PUBLIC ANSWERS. PUBLIC ACCOUNTABILITY.

Kwaela News Network — The archive of Taita Taveta County news and information.

 

Kwaela News Network

Leave a Comment
Share
Published by
Kwaela News Network

Recent Posts

TAITA TAVETA: SEVEN DAYS HAVE ELAPSED — HAS SENATOR KAJWANG SENT WAKUJAA’S GOVERNMENT FILES TO EACC?

  By Kwaela News Network (KNN) | Governance & Accountability The seven-day ultimatum issued to…

16 hours ago

THE ERA OF POLITICAL EUPHORIA IN TAITA TAVETA COUNTY IS OVER

  The days when political party waves and symbolism single-handedly determined election outcomes in Taita-Taveta…

1 day ago

TAITA TAVETA: CAN THE DCI CRACK THE NUT? DORCAS MLGHU’S PUBLIC OUTBURST PUTS COUNTY EXECUTIVE UNDER FRESH PRESSURE

  The growing controversy surrounding the financial management of Taita Taveta County has taken another…

2 days ago

THE GOVERNOR DISCOVERS FISCAL DISCIPLINE — FOUR YEARS TOO LATE?

  Perhaps one of the most ironic moments of Governor Andrew Mwadime's appearance before the…

3 days ago

NDARA B LAND DISPUTE: 63 RESIDENTS SERVED WITH THREE-MONTH EVICTION NOTICE FOLLOWING COURT RULING

Affected families in Mlambenyi, Golani and Mto Mwagodi face a February 2027 deadline as the…

3 days ago

THE WRONG TIME: GOVERNOR WAKUJAA’S DEFENCE

During a Senate Public Finance Committee meeting, Taita Taveta Governor Andrew Mwadime, popularly known as…

5 days ago