Categories: *Featured News

PETITIONERS FAIL TO PROVE OWNERSHIP OF 1,306 HECTARES AS COURT DISMISSES NDARA B LAND CASE

Case: Gadiel Mnyambo Mwaisama & Others v Ndara B Community, Trustees of Diaspora University Town & Others
Court: Environment and Land Court of Kenya
Case No.: ELC Petition No. E001 of 2023
Judge: E. K. Wabwoto
Date of Judgment: 29 June 2026

Background

The Petitioners, representing residents of Mlambenyi, Golani and Mto Mwagodi villages in Taita Taveta County, claimed that they and their ancestors had occupied part of the land formerly known as Sagalla/Ndara “B”/1 since the 1950s. They argued that their long occupation entitled them to ownership through adverse possession and that their constitutional rights had been violated when the land was registered as community land and portions allocated to other entities.

The Petitioners sought:

  • Recognition of ownership through adverse possession;
  • Orders compelling the National Land Commission to survey and excise the occupied land and issue title deeds;
  • Declarations that their constitutional rights had been violated;
  • Compensation for alleged destruction of property and crops; and
  • Costs of the suit.

The Respondents opposed the Petition, maintaining that the land is registered community land belonging to the Ndara B Community and that portions had lawfully been allocated to the Diaspora University Town project and mining interests.


Key Findings of the Court

1. Claim of Adverse Possession Failed

The Court found that the Petitioners failed to prove the essential elements required for adverse possession.

Specifically:

  • They did not identify specific parcels occupied by individual claimants.
  • The court-ordered survey established only a broad collective claim covering approximately 1,306 hectares spread across several registered parcels.
  • No clear evidence was produced showing individual homes, boundaries, graves, cultivation, or exclusive occupation.
  • The alleged occupation was interrupted by disputes and engagements with government authorities, which contradicted the requirement for uninterrupted and hostile possession.

The Court also held that the land is registered community land protected under the Constitution and the Community Land Act, and no evidence of fraud, illegality or misrepresentation was presented to challenge the registered title.


2. Mandamus Orders Could Not Be Granted

The Court declined to compel the National Land Commission to survey and allocate land because:

  • The National Land Commission was not a party to the proceedings.
  • No evidence was presented showing that the Commission had refused to perform a legal duty.
  • The land sought was already subdivided into various registered parcels held by different owners.
  • The orders sought would affect third-party rights without those parties being before the Court.

The Court held that mandamus cannot be used to create ownership rights that have not first been legally established.


3. Constitutional Rights Violations Were Not Proven

The Petitioners alleged violations of their rights under Articles 28, 40 and 43 of the Constitution, including unlawful evictions, intimidation and destruction of homes.

However, the Court found that:

  • The evidence was insufficient.
  • Photographs produced did not clearly identify the location or ownership of the alleged demolished structures.
  • No credible evidence linked the alleged acts to any specific Respondent.
  • No eviction notices or formal eviction processes were produced.

Consequently, the Court held that constitutional violations had not been proved.


4. Damages Were Not Awarded

Since no constitutional violation or unlawful conduct was established, the Court declined to award damages.

The Court also noted that:

  • No valuation reports were produced.
  • No proof of ownership of the allegedly destroyed structures was provided.
  • No evidence quantified the alleged loss of crops or property.

5. The Petition Was Procedurally Defective

The Court held that the Petition itself was not the proper legal vehicle for the reliefs sought.

According to the Court:

  • Claims for adverse possession should be filed through an Originating Summons under the Limitation of Actions Act, not through a constitutional petition.
  • The Petition failed to precisely demonstrate how constitutional rights had been violated.
  • The Petition sought orders affecting parties who were not before the Court.
  • The Petitioners had not fully exhausted dispute-resolution mechanisms available under the Community Land Act.

Observation Regarding Taita Taveta County Government

The Court strongly criticised the County Government of Taita Taveta for failing to participate in the proceedings despite being served and having significant responsibilities relating to land matters.

Justice Wabwoto described the County Government’s conduct as inappropriate for a public institution and inconsistent with the constitutional standards expected of public bodies.

See Judgement: Judgment (ELC E001 of 23)


Final Orders

The Court ordered that:

  1. The Petition dated 29 September 2023 be dismissed in its entirety.
  2. No declaration of ownership by adverse possession be granted.
  3. No order of mandamus be issued.
  4. No damages be awarded.
  5. The Petitioners remain free to pursue remedies available under the Community Land Act and through the mechanisms recommended by Parliament concerning membership of the Ndara B Community.
  6. Any future eviction must strictly comply with constitutional and statutory due-process requirements.
  7. Each party shall bear its own costs.

Significance of the Judgment

This judgment is significant because it reaffirms that:

  • Adverse possession claims must be supported by clear and specific evidence of occupation.
  • Registered community land enjoys strong legal protection under the Constitution and the Community Land Act.
  • Constitutional petitions cannot be used as substitutes for ordinary land claims where alternative legal procedures exist.
  • Even where land claims fail, any future evictions must still comply with constitutional safeguards and due process.

In practical terms, the Court did not determine that the Petitioners have no grievances, but rather that they failed to prove ownership rights through the legal route they chose and on the evidence presented. The Court left open other legal and administrative avenues for resolving disputes concerning membership and rights within the Ndara B Community.

Mwachere Shuma

Leave a Comment

View Comments

Share
Published by
Mwachere Shuma

Recent Posts

TAITA TAVETA: SEVEN DAYS HAVE ELAPSED — HAS SENATOR KAJWANG SENT WAKUJAA’S GOVERNMENT FILES TO EACC?

  By Kwaela News Network (KNN) | Governance & Accountability The seven-day ultimatum issued to…

18 hours ago

THE ERA OF POLITICAL EUPHORIA IN TAITA TAVETA COUNTY IS OVER

  The days when political party waves and symbolism single-handedly determined election outcomes in Taita-Taveta…

1 day ago

TAITA TAVETA: CAN THE DCI CRACK THE NUT? DORCAS MLGHU’S PUBLIC OUTBURST PUTS COUNTY EXECUTIVE UNDER FRESH PRESSURE

  The growing controversy surrounding the financial management of Taita Taveta County has taken another…

2 days ago

THE GOVERNOR DISCOVERS FISCAL DISCIPLINE — FOUR YEARS TOO LATE?

  Perhaps one of the most ironic moments of Governor Andrew Mwadime's appearance before the…

3 days ago

NDARA B LAND DISPUTE: 63 RESIDENTS SERVED WITH THREE-MONTH EVICTION NOTICE FOLLOWING COURT RULING

Affected families in Mlambenyi, Golani and Mto Mwagodi face a February 2027 deadline as the…

3 days ago

THE WRONG TIME: GOVERNOR WAKUJAA’S DEFENCE

During a Senate Public Finance Committee meeting, Taita Taveta Governor Andrew Mwadime, popularly known as…

6 days ago