Legal Opinion exposes Irregular Appointment
Fresh questions are emerging over governance and adherence to the rule of law in Taita Taveta County after an official legal advisory concluded that the re-engagement of a senior county officer was “procedurally irregular and legally unsustainable.”
The findings contained in Legal Advisory No. 02/2026, issued by the Office of the County Solicitor on 10 March 2026, paint a troubling picture of apparent disregard for constitutional principles, public service regulations and prudent management of public resources.
More significantly, the advisory raises broader concerns about leadership, accountability and the culture of favoritism that critics say has increasingly characterized Governor Andrew Mwadime’s administration.
According to the advisory, Mr. Erasmus Mwamburi Mwanyasi’s contract expired on 16 November 2024, after which he formally cleared from service and was issued with a Certificate of Service under Section 51 of the Employment Act. This certificate legally confirmed the termination of the employment relationship.
The officer thereafter remained outside the county public service for approximately eighteen months before the County Public Service Board purported to “renew” his contract on 28 January 2026 for a further three years.
However, the County Solicitor found that an eighteen-month break in service extinguished the previous contractual relationship, making it impossible in law to characterize the engagement as a renewal. Instead, the purported renewal constituted an entirely new appointment.
Legal Advisory 02 Renewal of Contract 10032026
The advisory further established that the officer had already attained the mandatory retirement age of sixty years in November 2024.
Public service regulations provide for retirement at sixty years, save for limited exceptions applicable to persons living with disabilities. No evidence was presented showing that such an exception applied in this case.
Perhaps most damaging is the finding that the purported appointment failed to comply with Article 232 of the Constitution and Sections 59 and 63 of the County Governments Act.
The legal opinion observed that any fresh appointment ought to have been preceded by:
None of these safeguards appear to have been followed.
The advisory consequently concluded that the engagement was procedurally irregular and legally unsustainable.
The findings inevitably fuel long-standing accusations that merit and transparency have increasingly been replaced by favoritism and patronage within sections of the county administration.
The Constitution is clear that appointments in public service must be based on fair competition and merit. Those principles exist precisely to prevent situations where individuals are handpicked and ushered into public office through the back door.
When vacancies are neither advertised nor subjected to competitive recruitment, deserving professionals are denied equal opportunity and public confidence in institutions is eroded.
The law exists to serve all citizens—not a privileged few.
While the County Public Service Board bears the immediate statutory mandate over recruitment, political responsibility ultimately rests with the Executive.
Governor Andrew Mwadime—popularly known as WAKUJAA—appoints members of the County Public Service Board, subject to approval by the County Assembly.
Consequently, questions surrounding irregular appointments cannot be isolated from the leadership style and governance culture prevailing under his administration.
Leadership is not merely about claiming credit when things go right; it is equally about accepting responsibility when institutions under one’s watch depart from the law.
The doctrine of accountability demands that the buck stops with the top leadership.
A governor cannot celebrate appointments when they are politically convenient and then distance himself when those appointments are subsequently declared unlawful.
Interestingly, despite finding the engagement legally unsustainable, the County Solicitor merely recommended that the County Public Service Board review the appointment and, if necessary, withdraw or regularize it.
Those recommendations appear considerably softer than the conclusions reached.
If an appointment is unlawful and incapable of being justified under the Constitution and public service regulations, the logical consequence should be immediate revocation rather than a further review process.
One cannot regularize what ought never to have occurred in the first place.
To restore public confidence and safeguard public resources, several measures are necessary.
The purported appointment should be revoked without delay.
No further salaries, allowances or benefits should be paid under an engagement already declared legally unsustainable.
A comprehensive investigation should determine:
Where irregular expenditure has occurred, appropriate recovery mechanisms should be pursued in accordance with the law.
Taxpayers should not bear the financial consequences of unlawful decisions made by public officials.
The county government must recommit itself to transparency, merit and competitive recruitment as envisioned under Article 232 of the Constitution.
Ultimately, this controversy transcends one individual.
It speaks to the quality of governance in Taita Taveta County.
Public office is a public trust.
County institutions are not private estates, and public jobs are not political rewards to be distributed among favorites.
Governor Andrew Mwadime and his team owe the people of Taita Taveta an explanation.
The people deserve to know how an appointment involving an officer who had retired, exited service, remained outside the public service for eighteen months and was never competitively recruited could nevertheless find its way back into government.
The people of Taita Taveta are entitled to competent leadership, fidelity to the Constitution and prudent use of public resources.
Nothing less should be acceptable.
Legal Advisory 02 Renewal of Contract 10032026
The views expressed herein are based on the findings and conclusions contained in Legal Advisory No. 02/2026 issued by the Office of the County Solicitor on 10 March 2026.
The days when political party waves and symbolism single-handedly determined election outcomes in Taita-Taveta…
The growing controversy surrounding the financial management of Taita Taveta County has taken another…
Perhaps one of the most ironic moments of Governor Andrew Mwadime's appearance before the…
Affected families in Mlambenyi, Golani and Mto Mwagodi face a February 2027 deadline as the…
During a Senate Public Finance Committee meeting, Taita Taveta Governor Andrew Mwadime, popularly known as…
Kwaela News Network | Editorial Taita Taveta County is confronting a governance crisis that can…
Leave a Comment