Categories: Reviews

Analysis of the Auditor-General’s Findings on the County Executive of Taita Taveta (FY 2024/2025)

The Auditor-General issued a Qualified Opinion, meaning the financial statements contained significant issues, although not severe enough to warrant an adverse opinion.

The report paints a picture of persistent weaknesses in financial management, procurement, governance, and compliance with the law.


1. Unsupported Cash Balances (Kshs.197.3 Million)

The County reported cash and cash equivalents of Kshs.197,278,782, but some cashbooks were not provided and several bank accounts were said to have been closed without evidence.

Implication

  • The Auditor could not verify whether the money actually existed.
  • There is a risk that balances may be misstated or unsupported.

2. Questionable Work in Progress (Kshs.112.6 Million)

The County reported work-in-progress worth Kshs.112.6 million, yet project reports showed:

  • Certified works totaling Kshs.301.6 million.
  • A variance of Kshs.189 million.
  • Physical inspections found incomplete projects worth Kshs.184.9 million.

Implication

  • Project values and completion status are unreliable.
  • Assets may have been overstated.

3. Unsupported Payables (Kshs.2.226 Billion)

The County owes suppliers and third parties Kshs.2.226 billion, but failed to provide ageing schedules.

Implication

  • Nobody can determine:
    • How old these debts are.
    • Whether some claims are invalid.
    • Which debts should be paid first.

4. Huge Unexplained Variances in Transfers to TAVEVO

The County recorded transfers of:

  • Kshs.610.8 million to TAVEVO.
  • Kshs.7 million to TAVEVO WSTF.

However, TAVEVO’s own books showed only:

  • Kshs.118.1 million.
  • Kshs.2.54 million.

Unexplained Differences

Entity Variance
TAVEVO Kshs.492.7 million
TAVEVO WSTF Kshs.4.46 million

Implication

Nearly half a billion shillings could not be reconciled.


5. Procurement Questions Over Fuel Expenditure

The County spent Kshs.74.6 million on fuel.

Included in this was Kshs.1.6 million spent on private vehicles used by the municipality, but procurement records were missing.

Implication

The Auditor could not establish whether:

  • The vehicles were properly hired.
  • The expenditure actually occurred.

6. Budget Performance Problems

Budgeted Revenue

Kshs.7.55 billion

Actual Revenue

Kshs.6.08 billion

Shortfall

Kshs.1.47 billion (19%)

Implication

Planned development and service delivery suffered because projected revenues were not achieved.


7. Twenty Previous Audit Issues Remain Unresolved

Problems raised in earlier years have still not been addressed.

Implication

There appears to be a recurring pattern of poor accountability.


REPORT ON LAWFULNESS AND EFFECTIVENESS

8. Illegal Handling of Hospital Revenue

Hospitals collected:

Kshs.72.17 million

Returned to hospitals:

Kshs.54.14 million

Balance withheld:

Kshs.18.03 million

The law requires these funds to remain in Facility Improvement Financing accounts.

Implication

Health facilities were deprived of resources needed for service delivery.


9. Breach of Fiscal Responsibility Principles

Development Spending Below Legal Threshold

Development budget:

29%

Legal minimum:

30%


Wage Bill Too High

Compensation of employees:

Kshs.3.81 billion

Representing:

46.5% of total revenue

Legal limit:

35%

Excess:

About 11.5 percentage points above the law.


County Assembly Allocation Too High

Allocation:

10%

Legal limit:

7%

Implication

The County violated Public Finance Management regulations.


10. Unremitted Employee Deductions

Outstanding deductions included:

Institution Amount
HELB Kshs.8.97 million
Pension Kshs.44.42 million
SACCOs Kshs.70.27 million
Total Kshs.123.66 million

Implication

Money deducted from employees was not forwarded to the intended institutions, exposing workers to penalties and financial distress.


11. Failure to Employ Persons with Disabilities

Employees:

3,288

PWD employees:

11

Representation:

0.3%

Legal requirement:

5%

Implication

The County is in breach of the Persons with Disabilities Act.


12. Long-Outstanding Bills Dating Back to 2014/2015

Old debts totaling:

Kshs.11.4 million

have remained unpaid for nearly a decade.

Implication

The County ignored regulations requiring old pending bills to be treated as first charges.


13. Missing Project Documents

Twenty-five projects worth Kshs.279.2 million had:

  • Missing site minutes.
  • Missing payment vouchers.
  • Missing certificates.
  • Missing inspection reports.

Five project files were completely unavailable.

No monthly progress reports were prepared.

No engineers’ estimates existed.

Implication

Transparency and value for money could not be established.


14. Defective Laundry Machines Worth Kshs.17.8 Million

Inspectors identified defects including:

  • Missing heaters.
  • Non-functional safety switches.
  • Missing hose pipes.

Despite these defects, the machines were accepted.

Implication

The Auditor could not confirm value for money.


15. Incomplete and Stalled Projects

Out of 12 projects worth Kshs.219.2 million:

  • 9 were incomplete.
  • 3 were stalled.

Result

The County failed to realize intended benefits from these investments.


INTERNAL CONTROL FAILURES

16. Vehicle Management Crisis

County fleet:

349 vehicles

Faulty vehicles:

91

Grounded and unusable:

21

Registration records missing for:

  • 37 vehicles.
  • 103 GK vehicles.
  • 39 privately registered vehicles.

Two vehicles even shared registration documents.

Implication

Asset management controls are weak.


17. Weak ICT Governance

The County lacked:

  • ICT Committee.
  • ICT Strategic Plan.
  • ICT Risk Framework.

Implication

Technology investments and cybersecurity risks are inadequately managed.


18. No Risk Management Policy

The County had no:

  • Risk management framework.
  • Fraud prevention mechanisms.
  • Disaster recovery plan.
  • Risk assessments.

Implication

The County is vulnerable to fraud, operational disruptions, and governance failures.

Read Also: Professional Analysis of the Taita Taveta FY 2025/2026 Supplementary II Budget


Overall Assessment

The report reveals four recurring themes:

1. Weak Financial Controls

  • Unsupported balances.
  • Missing records.
  • Unreconciled transfers.

2. Persistent Non-Compliance

  • Breaches of the PFM Act.
  • Failure to remit deductions.
  • Violation of disability employment requirements.

3. Procurement and Project Management Weaknesses

  • Missing files.
  • Defective equipment.
  • Stalled projects.

4. Governance Failures

  • Lack of risk management.
  • Weak ICT controls.
  • Poor asset management.

Key Numbers at a Glance

Issue Amount
Unsupported cash Kshs.197.3 million
Unsupported work in progress Kshs.112.6 million
Trade and other payables Kshs.2.226 billion
TAVEVO unexplained variance Kshs.492.7 million
Fuel procurement queried Kshs.1.6 million
Hospital funds not reimbursed Kshs.18 million
Unremitted employee deductions Kshs.123.7 million
Defective laundry machines Kshs.17.8 million
Incomplete/stalled projects Kshs.219.2 million
Budget shortfall Kshs.1.47 billion

Conclusion

The Auditor-General’s report suggests that the County Executive of Taita Taveta faces deep-rooted problems in accountability, compliance, project execution, and internal controls. Although the opinion issued was qualified rather than adverse, the repeated unresolved issues and multiple breaches of the law indicate a need for substantial reforms in financial management and governance.

Click below for the Full OAG Report.

AUDITOR_GENERALS_REPORT_ON_COUNTY_GOVERNMENTS_COUNTY_EXECUTIVES

Mwachere Shuma

Leave a Comment
Share
Published by
Mwachere Shuma

Recent Posts

TAITA TAVETA: SEVEN DAYS HAVE ELAPSED — HAS SENATOR KAJWANG SENT WAKUJAA’S GOVERNMENT FILES TO EACC?

  By Kwaela News Network (KNN) | Governance & Accountability The seven-day ultimatum issued to…

18 hours ago

THE ERA OF POLITICAL EUPHORIA IN TAITA TAVETA COUNTY IS OVER

  The days when political party waves and symbolism single-handedly determined election outcomes in Taita-Taveta…

1 day ago

TAITA TAVETA: CAN THE DCI CRACK THE NUT? DORCAS MLGHU’S PUBLIC OUTBURST PUTS COUNTY EXECUTIVE UNDER FRESH PRESSURE

  The growing controversy surrounding the financial management of Taita Taveta County has taken another…

2 days ago

THE GOVERNOR DISCOVERS FISCAL DISCIPLINE — FOUR YEARS TOO LATE?

  Perhaps one of the most ironic moments of Governor Andrew Mwadime's appearance before the…

3 days ago

NDARA B LAND DISPUTE: 63 RESIDENTS SERVED WITH THREE-MONTH EVICTION NOTICE FOLLOWING COURT RULING

Affected families in Mlambenyi, Golani and Mto Mwagodi face a February 2027 deadline as the…

3 days ago

THE WRONG TIME: GOVERNOR WAKUJAA’S DEFENCE

During a Senate Public Finance Committee meeting, Taita Taveta Governor Andrew Mwadime, popularly known as…

6 days ago