Foremost. The Objective of the above captioned PRESS RELEASE-a paid advert- is unclear. Lots of contradictions, innuendos and mis-information. On behalf of the Njoro Kubwa Bulk Water Project developers, we wish to set the record straight.
Legality of the Njoro Bulk water Project.
The Njoro Kubwa Bulk water (NBW)Project has two parties; (1) TAVEVO Water & Sewerage Company (TAVEVO)
(2) A consortium of 4 Private entities including Miraadi Limited. Upon award of contract, the 4 private partners, formed a project Company called Miradi Water Limited. Project Companies also known as Special Purpose Vehicles are normally formed after the award of contract. It is a requirement under the PPP Act to have a new project company formed after award of contract but before Financial close. In these types of transactions, project companies are never formed at bidding stage.
TAVEVO’s independence as a contracting authority.
TAVEVO has an Independent procurement department and as such an independent contracting authority. The Procurement laws of Kenya allows Water Service Companies to procure goods and services without prior consent from County Governments. The Fact is the NBW project is not a County Government Project.
The truth about NBW Project Financing.
Despite all the misleading information in the media both print, Local FM radio and electronic; the project funds have not been approved. The private developers’ expenditures on consultancy fees towards feasibility studies and Design comes from their own private funds. In addition, the public is hereby informed that there is NO loan agreement in place with TAVEVO or the County Government and there will never be any such Loan agreement because the project is privately funded so no risk to TAVEVO, County or National Government. Even the loan guarantee is being raised by the private investment team.
Location and beneficiaries the Project:
The NBW Project covers the entire County of Taita Taveta. Whereas the main beneficiary in terms of water consumption will be Taveta Sub County, The Njoro Kubwa Project will cover 145Km of large diameter water pipeline from Taveta to Voi with branches at Makitau to Kishushe also a Line via Mwatate to supply water to most of the ranches and residents of Kasigau. The planned Pipeline route runs along Public roads. The small beneficiaries are more than 150,000 residents of Taita Taveta County, at least 500 small scale farmers and all the ranches from the Water supply. The largest beneficiary is actually the County Government as it stands to earn at least Ksh 690million in revenue collection annually from year 3 of the project operation. That said; the NBW Project will be the first ever privately funded and operated water project in Sub Sahara Africa that generates revenue for a public institution or Local Government without a single monetary contribution from the beneficiary Public institution.
Communication with National Government agencies.
We can affirmatively confirm that The Ministry of Water & Sanitation and Coast Water Services Board are fully aware of the NBW project with written correspondence as proof. All project approvals on record have been issued from National Government agencies and include adverts in more than two (2) Nationwide newspapers.
Communication with County Government.
The developers of the Njoro Kubwa project communicate with both arms of Government; The Executive and County Assembly via written correspondence. The current Administration has had written communication with the Developer dated October 2017 just 45 days after taking office. That communication was copied to TAVEVO Managing Director and Deputy Governor. In addition, an Investment review meeting was held at the Governor’s office on November 16 2017. The project foreign and local partners were present at that November 2017 meeting.
Ownership of project Joint Venture partners.
Complete details of ownership, financial records and Names of Directors of the Project partners were submitted in the
Bid document dated December 2 2016. The assertion that ownership is not known is false and mischievous.
Did the County Delegation visit a non- existent entity for due diligence? How did they get their Visa approvals? Has anyone in County Government contacted the respective embassies to verify the existence of those Companies? Why is the County Government interested in the ownership of a Project awarded by an Independent Procurement body?
Chronology of Activities from 2015-2017 with TAVEVO?
The sequence presented by the author of the Press release is misleading and tends to purport an agenda that is a fiction of the mind of the author. Dealings with TAVEVO started in 2016. Further, MOUs are legal documents in Kenya.
The author ought to have informed the public what the MOU was all about and the necessary transitions from County Government to TAVEVO.
Public Forums with Elected leadership.
There have been several Public forums going back to January 2015 attended by local MPs and Several MCAs.
Attendance registers exist. Between November 19 2018 and January 4 2019 The current County executive
administration was invited to two (2) public forums in Taveta and Voi respectively. No representatives from Taita Taveta County Government showed up.
Project Letter of Award.
There is only one (1) NBW project for Ksh 6.22 Billion signed on February 28 2017. It must be noted that a letter of Award is not a Contract or valid agreement. Letters of Award can be revoked or amended before signing of the Contract. The Letter of award dated February 3 2017 is the valid letter. It clearly states that it supersedes any previous letters issued.
Sequence of tender award.
The NBW bid process was a 2 stage Request for Proposals (RFP) as specified in section 99 Procurement regulations.
1. Tender was advertised on November 17 2016. Sealed Proposals were open in public on December 2 2016.
2. There was competition from Chinese firms.
3. Evaluation was done between December 2016 and early January 2017 under oversight of an agent recommended by the PPOA.
4. Project was awarded on 3 rd February 2017 pending a Project development agreement.
5. Contract for Joint Development and Financing not for construction was signed on February 28 2017.
6. The County Legal officer in charge then was invited to witness the Award and agreement process.
It is common practise in Kenya to award projects within 45-60 days after Bids are opened. The entire NBW bid process from RFP advertisement to Contract singing took 104 days. Twice as long as the average duration.
Project Status reports.
These have been periodically issued to TAVEVO in writing Between March 1 2017 and June 30 2018. In total, 8 progress reports were issued with email attachments including 2 copied to the current Deputy Governor and the current Chairman of TAVEVO respectively.
Has TAVEVO made or received any payments to or from the Project partners?
NO. The project is for Design, Finance Build and Operate then handover to TAVEVO after 20 years. Both The County Government of Taita Taveta and TAVEVO Water Company do not qualify for loans of that magnitude. The County Government should present written evidence to the office of the Public Prosecutor and Auditor General as proof of unauthorized Loans or expenditures by TAVEVO and County Government made by private individuals.
Validation of commercial Viability.
The Project model contemplates that the Private entity will cover their own Investment risk. That in essence is the spirit of Privately Initiated Investment Proposals and Design Build +Finance Investmentsin Kenya. Nevertheless; There is a detailed Financial model submitted to County Government through TAVEVO; both to the current CECM Water & Irrigation and current Chairman TAVEVO Board. That information was submitted in July 2018.
FACT: The project Financial model has been verified by International Financial Engineers of impeccable repute. Indeed, it is the Financier (the lender) who does the viability analysis not the beneficiary.
The Question: Why is the County Government so keen now to re-engineer project Commercial viability after the Financiers have given a thumbs up? Which comes first; Viability analysis or Loan disbursement. If the County Government are saying in public that money was already disbursed why another “viability analysis?”
Objection by the County Govt to Miraadi Limited application for Water use permit.
The matter regarding an objection to Miraadi Ltd application for Water Use permit is well documented. The Developers’ response to Water Resources Authority (WRA) is on record. The reasons for the Objection raised by the County Government were all invalidated by the applicant. Not a single reason for Objection has merit in law. In addition, the County Government was invited by WRA to an arbitration meeting on November 30 2018 at WRA regional offices, Loitoktok. The County Government failed to send an apology or a representative. Thus County Government invariably failed to defend their flimsy points of objection before the applicant when called upon to do so.
Expenditure of Ksh 500-odd Million by Project Partners for development.
To demonstrate that the Ksh 500 million story is fictions; Please refer to an Article appearing in the Sunday Nation of September 23 entitled Riddle of Loan bigger than Company…which claims in part that Amiantit a company in South Africa was paid a similar amount. The press advert says Amiantit Spain spent Ksh 500-odd million. So which is the true position? Amiantit South Africa was paid by TAVEVO or Amiantit Spain spent Ksh 500-odd millions. Then on local FM radio one MCA says that monies were borrowed and paid out to the Developer and contractor. This is not a lack of understanding of how project finance is undertaken. It is deliberate action to mislead the public.
Alleged Transgressions to the Public Finance Management Act.
The Njoro Kubwa project was administered under the Public Procurement regulation section 99 processes. There is NO mention in the Procurement Act of alignment of turnkey RFPs to the Public Finance Management (PFM) Act neither is the funding based on Public Finance. The Project funds once approved remain Private. The reference to the PFM Act is utterly irrelevant and serious misapplication of that law by a public servant.
Access to the Water resource at Njoro Springs.
TAVEVO Water and Sewerage Company does not have a valid license to Abstract water at Njoro Kubwa Springs. The County Government on the other could petition WRA to expedite an application but in essence has no authority to apply for a water use permit on behalf of TAVEVO or third parties. The County Government is here admitting to the public that they only just filed an application for Water Abstraction from a Resource TAVEVO has been using for more than 10 years contrary to the provisions of the Water Act 2016.
So what is the issue?
The issue is not about procurement irregularities or Lack of documentation. The issue is about some fictitious Ksh 500-
odd million that was allegedly poured in Taita Taveta in 2017. If the author truly stands by the allegations in the PRESS
STATEMENT of January 17 appearing in the Standard, that person should have signed the Press Statement and
presented evidence to the Public Prosecutor or Ethics and Anti-Corruption Commission (EACC).
Proposed Action
The project development team is pursuing all necessary legal means to expose the misinformation being peddled by some key officials of the County Government of Taita Taveta about the NBW Project.
Signed,
Tony Mwaruwa,
Lead developer and Project Manager.
For and behalf of the Njoro Kubwa Bulk Water project partners.
more recommended stories
TAITA TAVETA COUNTY GOVERNMENT’S SHAME ON DISPLAYWhen a county’s Chief Executive.
GODOMA TITLE DEEDS: A HISTORIC MILESTONE MARRED BY QUESTIONS OVER ACCURACYGODOMA – BURA, TAITA TAVETA, Residents.
QUESTIONS MOUNT OVER APPOINTMENT OF NEW COUNTY INSPECTORATE DIRECTOR IN TAITA TAVETAA cloud of uncertainty is.
FROM COUNTY HALL TO PPCK: GRANTON SAMBOJA’S LEADERSHIP RECORD FACES RENEWED SCRUTINYFormer Taita Taveta Governor Granton Samboja.
WHO IS JUSTICE AMRAPHAEL MBOGHOLI MSAGHA? THE TAITA SON WHO ROSE TO THE SUMMIT OF KENYA’S JUDICIARY In the hills of Taita Taveta.
Decisive Leadership, Not Polite Governance, Is What Taita Taveta NeedsBy all accounts, leadership is not.
MWANGEKA WA MALOWAKufuma konkala Wadawida ndewerekoghe na.
TAITA TAVETA LANDS CECM MOVES TO COURT OVER SALARY ARREARS AND REMOVAL DISPUTEMOMBASA, KENYA — Taita Taveta.
MRAMBA COMMUNITY LAND: COMMUNITY DEMANDS SWIFT REGISTRATION AS LEGAL AND GOVERNANCE DISPUTES CONTINUEResidents of the eight communities that.
WHOSE LAND? WHOSE MONEY?Members Demand Answers Over Qwetu Sacco’s.
Analysis of the Auditor-General’s Findings on the County Executive of Taita Taveta (FY 2024/2025)The Auditor-General issued a Qualified Opinion,.
SH320 MILLION, SH8,000 A DAY: THE COSTLY FAILURE OF MAUNGU LORRY PARKThe story of Maungu Lorry.
EACC REPORT EXPOSES IRREGULAR SPENDING AND PROCUREMENT VIOLATIONS AT TAITA TAVETA COUNTY ASSEMBLYVoi, Kenya – The latest quarterly.
EXPOSÉ | WATER PAID, SERVICE DENIEDInside the payment breakdown linking TAVEVO.
50 YEARS OF DRY TAPS: THE SHAME OF MWASOKO WATER PROJECTHow a 1975 Government Water Scheme.
KSH 500 MILLION IN QUESTION: AUDIT EXPOSES DEEP FINANCIAL CRACKS AT TAVEVOBy Kwaela News Network Investigations Desk.

Leave a Comment