MEDICAL PRACTITIONERS EVICTION, WHO IS INHUMANE IN THIS SAGA? BE THE JURY

By Geoffrey Kimonge mbogo

Late last year there was what looked like an outbreak of strikes by the MEDICAL fraternity in Kenya while the whole world was still fighting the ‘notorious’ COVID-19 pandemic. Taita Taveta County wasn’t spared their share of strikes with 409 Nurses and Clinical officers and the Doctors in the county downing their tools for the better part of December, 2020.

The issues raised by the Healthcare workers Union were as follows:

i. Re-designation

ii. Promotions – first, second and subsequent

iii. Lack of PPEs

iv. Designated facility for handling health care workers and county staff infected with Covid-19.

v. Comprehensive insurance cover

vi. Improvement of staff welfare

vii. Additional recruitment of health care workers

viii. Enhancement of Health Risk Allowance

The County Government of Taita Taveta prioritized to handle issues touching on health care workers over the rest of the other county departments ‘staff. The following was undertaken;

a) Re-designation of 34 health care workers.

b) Effected 80 first promotions.

c) Re-grading of 45 health care workers.

d) Initiated the process of effecting 144 second promotions including placing an internal advertisement for the subsequent promotions

e) Ensuring there is adequate supply of quality PPEs

f) Scaling up efforts of completing the construction of the 160 bed county isolation ward; including setting aside a facility to handle health care workers and county staff infected with Covid-19.

g) Renewal of county employees’ comprehensive insurance cover

h) Ensured timely payment of staff salaries compared to other counties where delays have been experienced for months and months

i) Continuous improvement of staff welfare and working environment procurement of working tools and equipment, infrastructural improvement

j) Always provided accommodation for health care workers taking care of Covid patients on a rotational basis; hence protecting their families from chances of exposure.

k) Additional recruitment of 284 health care workers across all cadres within a period of one year.

In a meeting held with the County Government of Taita Taveta on 11th December 2020, the County Union Officials agreed to suspend the county strike notice after the employer TTCG met all the above conditions however, in a rather ‘bizarre’ turn of events, following advise/ instructions from the Union Nairobi Headquarters, the Nurses chose to keep away from their workstations regardless of the fact that at the local level most of their grievances had been addressed.

On the 16th December 2020, the Employment and Labour Relations Court in Nairobi in Cause No. E6494 of 2020, Cabinet Secretary Ministry of Health Vs. Kenya National Union of Clinical Officers (KUCO), Kenya National Union of Nurses (KNUN) and four others, the Court suspended the National Strike. The effect of that is that all health care workers as at 16th December were required to resume duty and allow conciliation.

The Council of Governors, through its resolutions communicated on 21st December 2020, Ref: COG/6/40 Vol.60 (89) unanimously agreed to follow the direction given by the Court, and that any health care worker who failed to resume duty was to have appropriate disciplinary action taken against him/her.

A circular was subsequently issued from the office of the county secretary, who is also the Head of County Public Service on 23rd December 2020, GOV/TT/ST.8/NR/VOL.I/95 directing all the health care workers on strike to resume duty, while clearly stipulating that disciplinary actions were going to be taken against those who failed to do so.

In the meantime hundreds of tax payers and citizens of Taita Taveta County were suffering due to this standoff resulting in over 60 patients being discharged from Moi County Referral Hospital including NEONATES (premature babies born before their time) who depended on incubators; theatre services had to be suspended or referred to private hospitals with caesarian cases costing the tax payer between 10 thousand shillings and 80 thousand shillings depending on where one got the services among other cases.

The county has been experiencing an average of 3 (three) avoidable deaths per day following this standoff with the normal traffic of approximately 300 patients for Moi Hospital, 160 patients for Mwatate Hospital, 130 patients for Wesu Hospital, 100 patients for Taveta Hospitals and 80 patients for Wundanyi Hospitals per day being denied this facility due to the strike; not mentioning the majority from the rural areas dependent on health centres and dispensaries.

It be known that all this suffering by citizens who are tax payers was not as a result of lack of medication or equipment but instead, a crisis caused by the strike.

As guided by the Human Resource Policies and Procedures Manual for the Public Service as well as the Discipline Manual for the Public Service and other related legislations, the relevant disciplinary processes had to be initiated against those who absented themselves from duty without any valid reason.

Show-cause letters were issued; those who failed to give a valid response were subsequently issued with dismissal letters. Those who were aggrieved by the decision made were advised to appeal to the County Public Service Board for consideration. The County Government wrote to the Ministry of Health on the Contractual UHC nurses and clinical officers who had equally kept off work for further disciplinary action over and above effecting stoppage of their salaries which has since been done.

On 8th January, 2021 those who didn’t submit their “show cause why” letters formerly issued were handed with dismissal letters as per their terms of contract which clearly gave them a timeline on when to handover all Government properties.

On 15th January, 2021 the County Public Services Board through an advertisement advertised to refill the vacant positions.

On 21st January, 2021 the Mombasa Employment and Labour Relations Court, in a case filed by the Kenya Union of Clinical Officers (Taita Taveta Branch) against the County Government of Taita Taveta and the County Public Service Board, issued an order directing the clinical officers to attempt to exhaust internal dispute resolution mechanism available including filing of APPEALS to the County Public Service Board. About 40 out of the 409 officers, who made their appeals, presented themselves to the board for consideration and were reinstated.

On 3rd February, 2021 by notice served to the dismissed staff, they were advised to vacate the Government quarters they occupy in order to pave way for the new staff that had been recruited to serve as their replacement.

Any eviction is painful and dehumanizing and often inhumane and so is the suffering of the citizens who are the tax payers in the hands of those they pay – Nurses. For how much longer were the Nurses going to be tolerated with their issues already resolved and all dispute mechanisms exhausted?

It is you the JURY to see whether you will identify with the plight of the NEONS and the helpless, the dying and the dead out of negligence of the Nurses or the eviction of Nurses who absconded their duty and gone against their vows to protect and save lives.

MEDICAL PRACTITIONERS EVICTION, WHO IS INHUMANE IN THIS SAGA? BE THE JURY. PART 2

more recommended stories