Categories: Opinion

Voi Lower Market Relocation Project: A symbol of the rising tide of Anti-wealth Creation mentality in Samboja Administration

Traders at the new Voi Market

By Oginga Randiki

Brief Background

Taita-Taveta County should be grateful that so many people are interested in making a living from trade. The traders creat wealth in an economy that is not creating little or no formal-sector jobs.

Therefore, an armed askari chasing street traders is hence the biggest symbol of anti-wealth creation mentality in the County. This bring us to one fundamental question; Is the county government really committed to tackling wealth creation in Taita- Taveta County?

It is an issue that has been the subject of much debate, with tough economic conditions,high unemployment leaving many residents fearing the worst for the poorer members of Taita-Taveta County society. Amid all this the Samboja Administration woke up one morning and decided to come up with an impromptu project titled Voi Lower Market Relocation Project.

But as this Social Audit Report highlights,the question should not be whether the Samboja administration should tackle the wealth creation, but how.

The social audit explores what has changed since the project started nearly a fortnight ago.

We conducted a social audit on the Voi Market Relocation Project. What’s a social audit? A social audit is the process through which all details of a public project are scrutinized at a public meeting.

A social audit seeks to evaluate how well public resources are being used and how to improve performance. It also aims to ensure maximum community participation.

A trader at the bew Voi Market

Here are the findings.

1. Project Selection Process: This is the first step in a project cycle. There was credible evidence to support claims that primary stakeholders at the Voi Lower Market were involved in the process of identifying the needs of its location or area. Neither was there any proof that, indeed, the primary stakeholders at the lower market chose relocation as an appropriate project to address those needs.

2. Voi Market Relocation Project is a Public project. A public project is any project that utilizes public fund.

3. Project site: the project is located on land belonging to the former Voi wholesale market project funded under the economic stimulus program on the Mombasa-Nairobi Highway, a few kilometers from the former Caltex filling Station, now Total Petrol station.

4. Project cost: approximately Ksh. 100m including the Ksh. 20m under the economic stimulus program disbursed under the Voi CDF 2010-2012

5. Project Management Committee Process: This is a committee responsible for implementation of a public project. There is no evidence to support the claim that Voi Lower Market Relocation Project Committee Members were democratically elected by the primary stakeholders at the market as clearly provided for under the law.

6. It was found out that a pre-existing team of four or five businesswomen who was only recently at serious logger head with the governor and was once summoned to Wundanyi to record statements with police on undisclosed utterances against the governor, was later given unfettered powers by the CEC trade to implement the project, possibly after patching up their indifferences.

7. Public Participation: The County goverment through County Executive Committee Member for Trade is compelled by the Constitution and County Government Act to involve numerous primary stakeholders in a project like this.

8. There was no evidence to proof that an effective cross-board consultative meetings were held with stakeholders to deliberate on how the CG intended to implement the various project cycles.

9. Although the CECM for trade was mandated to organize, engage hawkers, street traders and stall owners for implementation and wealth creation, no credible evidence exists to support her claims of active engagement of traders at any level at all, besides the technical appearance she made like a clinical officer holding brief for senior neurologist

Governor Granton Samboja at the new voi market after he officially opened it

10. Project Implementation Plan/ Work Plan: This is the principal working document for and project. The Work Plan gives a summary of all the project activities, their cost, date, and who is responsible for them.

11. Although government guidelines direct that all public projects must have a Work Plan, and that this is the basis for the release of any funds to the project, it was sadly found out that there was no existing Work Plan for the Voi Lower Market Relocation Project. The project was run on the ‘whistle blow, whistle stop basis’.

12. Space Application Modules: Although a project like Voi Lower Market Relocation Project should have operational module designed to deal with application for space and stalls, which may be a web-based application or manual and must be centralized.

13. It was unfortunately found out that Application Modules were not created by the CECM for Trade to handle applications from hawkers, streets traders, traders at the lower market and freshers.

14. The resultant negative impact was that the project was run without the core modules like the planning desk, the front desk, the application desk, the processing desk, the investigation desk, the revenue desk and the report desk.

15. Due to lack of the core modules, a number of project implementation related problems were identified during the social audit.

16. 1. Rampant illicit sale of space or plot.

17. 2. Self-allocation of space/ plots by traders and senior county government officials and other political campaigners.

18. 3. Squatting leading to a proliferation of spaces spilling over to land owed by Voi Sisal,Estate and road reserves.

19. 4. Unlawful space sub-divisions and change of use.

20. 5. Haphazard and unregulated space development giving rise to structures in defiance of the approved land use plans.

21. 6. Space/ plots speculation leading to one individual mostly by members of the team grabbing space enough for five stalls and renting out or selling the rest to individuals.

22. 7. Misuse and poor space management by the CECM for Trade.

23. Conflicts over unused or undeveloped space.

24. CECM for Trade was unable to curb illegal space transactions, space speculation by identifying speculators in the CG and the team, enforcing development compliance, resolving and preventing space/stall disputes,and identifying undeveloped space and idle or vacant space to allocate to school leavers.

25. Clear cases of lack of transparency and consistency in the implementation of project and unfair practices with regard to forceful closure of the Voi Lower Market. 26. Corrupt and non-transparent procedures in the allocation of space/ stalls.

27. The one size fits all approach by the CECM for Trade do not work at all.

28. The Voi Lower Market Relocation project has not achieved it priority objective. It has relocated traders but has failed to transfer the business together with the traders thus killing the enterprise in a county which is not creating enough jobs, relocating the market while leaving business behind in town is therefore suicidal.

29. The CECM for Trade has the perception that street trader is a nuisance and should be banished from the streets by any means necessary because he or she is an irritant, blocks roads and leads to an increase in crime.

Kwaela News Network

Leave a Comment
Share
Published by
Kwaela News Network

Recent Posts

TAITA TAVETA: SEVEN DAYS HAVE ELAPSED — HAS SENATOR KAJWANG SENT WAKUJAA’S GOVERNMENT FILES TO EACC?

  By Kwaela News Network (KNN) | Governance & Accountability The seven-day ultimatum issued to…

17 hours ago

THE ERA OF POLITICAL EUPHORIA IN TAITA TAVETA COUNTY IS OVER

  The days when political party waves and symbolism single-handedly determined election outcomes in Taita-Taveta…

1 day ago

TAITA TAVETA: CAN THE DCI CRACK THE NUT? DORCAS MLGHU’S PUBLIC OUTBURST PUTS COUNTY EXECUTIVE UNDER FRESH PRESSURE

  The growing controversy surrounding the financial management of Taita Taveta County has taken another…

2 days ago

THE GOVERNOR DISCOVERS FISCAL DISCIPLINE — FOUR YEARS TOO LATE?

  Perhaps one of the most ironic moments of Governor Andrew Mwadime's appearance before the…

3 days ago

NDARA B LAND DISPUTE: 63 RESIDENTS SERVED WITH THREE-MONTH EVICTION NOTICE FOLLOWING COURT RULING

Affected families in Mlambenyi, Golani and Mto Mwagodi face a February 2027 deadline as the…

3 days ago

THE WRONG TIME: GOVERNOR WAKUJAA’S DEFENCE

During a Senate Public Finance Committee meeting, Taita Taveta Governor Andrew Mwadime, popularly known as…

5 days ago