Categories: Opinion

TAITA TAVETA COUNTY EXECUTIVE Vs ASSEMBLY: WHO IS FOOLING WHO?

 

Let’s get first things first by understanding the background. The County Executive prepared a budget and delivered it to the County Assembly for approval. The Assembly didn’t refuse to approve. They did approve. But, with amendments. When the budget went back to the Governor for signing, he declined. Why? The MCAs had made significant amendments that the Governor believed were not good for the County.

Second, lets understand the development budget. The total budget is 1.84 billion. Development Partners are giving us Ksh 0.74 billion which is incontestable. The balance of Ksh 1.1 billion is the problem. The County Executive proposed to give the MCAs about Ksh 630m to share, giving each ward an average of Ksh 31.5m (incl. pending bills) while the Executive proposed to retain the balance of about Ksh 470.0 m. Let’s do a further breakdown: The MCA were to undertake 361 small projects averaging Ksh 1.7m each. The Executive was to do 91 projects each averaging Ksh 5.0m. in fact, if you discount bursaries and DATU fund and other recurrent expenses which are erroneously captured as development projects, the average drops to below Ksh 4.0m per project.


The MCAs looked at the budget and felt it didn’t address Mkitinas concerns. Eg Executive proposed to allocate Ksh 2.3m for bursaries per ward. They wanted Ksh 5.0m. You see, the MCAs have this thing called Ward Equalisation Fund. A vote minting machine. It has been on an upward trajectory and they felt last year they deserved each Ksh 30.0m which was later reduced to about Ksh 20.0m. They felt they needed to claw back their balance of Ksh 10m lost last year and add onto the 31.5m given this year. The challenge was, how do they raise about Ksh 183m that will ensure each ward ends up with Ksh 40 plus millions.

A decision to mutilate the budget estimates and bridge the gap was made. First, the wage bill is too high. Everybody says so. Ksh 100.0m was chucked off from money meant to pay casuals. “After all, there are very many ghost workers and busybodies hanging around the executive doing nothing”, they reasoned. Next on their sight were legal fees and Ksh 20.0m was slashed. Next were funds to settle a NHC loan for Mbela Estate and Ksh 20.0m here also went. “This is a long term loan. Why should it all be cleared at once?”. “A part payment of Ksh 12m can do for now”. The Communications Department and the County Public Service Board were not spared either. Ksh 7.0m and Ksh 6.0m were swiftly deducted from them respectively. By now they had Ksh 153.0m. In summary, they still managed to get the balance of Ksh 30m by raiding the County Secretary and Finance among other departments. Having amassed the loot, they shared among themselves each ward getting Ksh41.6m.

By doing so, they infuriated the Governor. He went livid. “How they dare to award themselves what they didn’t deserve in the first place”. He comes up with a hard hitting rejoinder that appears to withdraw any concessions or goodwill he had extended to MCAs before. “No more 41 or 31 million. Infact, the most you will get is Ksh15 million plus Ksh 5 million for pending bills. Nothing more” He responds. “Also, all pending bills totalling Ksh 414million must be provided for in the budget without exception and that is in addition to you undoing all what you have un-procedurally done” he continues.

How shall all this be possible? If the budget is redone as it was, where will the extra funds to pay all pending bills that were not factored initially come from? The Governor decides to hit where it hurts. It must come from a reduction in the Assembly budget to within 7% of the County Revenue totals. “They must obey the law. Even the Senate said so”. There will be a saving of Ksh 228m that can be used to clear some pending bills. The die has been cast. Who will blink first.


Interestingly, consider this:

The Executive budget proposals sent to the Assembly for approval had exceeded the 7% threshold for the county assembly. The Assembly approved. The Executive has now turned against the Assembly for approving beyond 7%. Whose fooling who?

The Executive says through its agents that Ward Fund doesn’t exist yet it had proposed about Ksh 31.5million for each ward for approval. Whose fooling who?

The Executive says MCAs have many small projects that are meaningless, yet they proposed for approval by the assembly, 361 small projects for MCAs and 91 small projects for Executive each costing an average of Ksh 3-4miilion. Whose fooling who?

Which mega projects did the executive propose that were not approved by the Assembly? None. So, whose fooling who?

The Budget minimum of 30% for development expenditure was met mischievously by transferring DATU funds, Education Bursaries and Scholarships, Purchase of Motor Vehicles and other recurrent expenditures to development side in order to increase the development vote and create the impression the minimum limit had been met. They wanted the assembly to approve this illegality. Which the assembly did for them. But now, the Assembly must follow the law. Who is fooling who?

From the foregoing, its quiet clear not much difference exists between the two sides. They are birds of the same feather. The sooner they start flocking together, the better for us all.

 

Kwaela News Network

Leave a Comment

View Comments

  • : Now look here ,complaining of 41M for every ward for projects while the CE budget to CA is very funny 👇👇

    The department of finance - has one CCO and CECM has this broken down items budgeted differently yet under one docket .. Going to 100M

    -Planning & Budgeting :35M

    -Accounting services :22M

    -Internal Audit services :11M

    -Revenue Management :29M

    -Supply chain management -5M

    All this total to - 100M

    👉Is this really fair ?

    100M for one department but itemised in the budget as different units or departments ?

    Office of the Gov -79M

    It hosts this itemised units (in the budgets shown as independent vote heads too)

    -communication &strategy : 11M

    - service delivery unit: 6M

    -special programs unit :6m

    - legal services :26M

    Total 128M (all falls under office of the Governor)

    This is not what the CE is not telling the people,
    In accounting all the units above fall under the office of Gov and should be not items/vote heads..

    Imagine budget of CE to CA

    Sport services has allocation of 28M

    Livestock -10M

    Vetinary has -9M.

    And *Mining* -5M 😟

    They threw out this budget and drew changes .

    Part of the changes is what was shared by CE trying to depict the MCA's has having bad faith towards the CE.

    The CE didn't surrender the CA reasons for rejecting their budget and why the changes to the public ..

    Their is *no any mega flagship project* in the budget sent to CA only *words* found in the Govs reasons for rejecting CA final budget .

    How can u give Fisheries department 3M, mining 5M of which both are economic booths and boths then give a social one - sports 28M ?

    Mining and fisheries department and industries is an open note for jobs

    • Nangojea kusoma majibu ya hayo maswali ya Who ia fooling who?

      Bila hivyo, hii kelele yote inatoka kwa Exec ni labbish Takataka Matuta 😛

      I tend to believe even some leaders who took sides with the exec might have not read and understood what the EXEC offered for approval!

      Ukweli ndio utakombia TTC, tuambiane ukweli wa mambo jinsi yalivyo!

      Si kupandisha watu hisia kwa baraza na kumbe ukweli wa mambo umefichwa...

      Someone please get courageous enough and share the budget proposal presented to the CA by the CE for approval!

      🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾

      • Can the CA publish what was presented to the Assembly for approval. This now smells like "sweetheart" deals gone sour and the Citizen are caught inbetween.

  • Its sad,soon nurses will go back to streets to demand for june salaries,taking too long to learn simple concepts.

Share
Published by
Kwaela News Network

Recent Posts

TAITA TAVETA: SEVEN DAYS HAVE ELAPSED — HAS SENATOR KAJWANG SENT WAKUJAA’S GOVERNMENT FILES TO EACC?

  By Kwaela News Network (KNN) | Governance & Accountability The seven-day ultimatum issued to…

18 hours ago

THE ERA OF POLITICAL EUPHORIA IN TAITA TAVETA COUNTY IS OVER

  The days when political party waves and symbolism single-handedly determined election outcomes in Taita-Taveta…

1 day ago

TAITA TAVETA: CAN THE DCI CRACK THE NUT? DORCAS MLGHU’S PUBLIC OUTBURST PUTS COUNTY EXECUTIVE UNDER FRESH PRESSURE

  The growing controversy surrounding the financial management of Taita Taveta County has taken another…

2 days ago

THE GOVERNOR DISCOVERS FISCAL DISCIPLINE — FOUR YEARS TOO LATE?

  Perhaps one of the most ironic moments of Governor Andrew Mwadime's appearance before the…

3 days ago

NDARA B LAND DISPUTE: 63 RESIDENTS SERVED WITH THREE-MONTH EVICTION NOTICE FOLLOWING COURT RULING

Affected families in Mlambenyi, Golani and Mto Mwagodi face a February 2027 deadline as the…

3 days ago

THE WRONG TIME: GOVERNOR WAKUJAA’S DEFENCE

During a Senate Public Finance Committee meeting, Taita Taveta Governor Andrew Mwadime, popularly known as…

6 days ago