Categories: Taita Taveta News

CHURU CHURU PROJECTS – GENESIS, IMPACT AND WAY FORWARD

By Peter Njenga

For a number of years now, datuzens have marveled at how Governors in other counties have managed to put up big infrastructural projects and wondered aloud why the same has never been witnessed in our home county of Taita Taveta. Instead, in the last decade, they have witnessed a plethora of small projects, such as supply of utensils and sufurias to villagers. These projects have now been famously christened as “Churu Churu” Projects by some social media commentators.

Before we vilify the Governors (past and present) it’s important to understand the genesis of such churu churu projects, their impact to the society and finally propose what can be done/adopted for improvement going forward. In order to lay a clear picture in simple terms, I will use the draft 2023/2024 itemised budget for illustration purposes.

In the draft budget, the total projected revenue is Ksh 7.04 billion. Out of this revenue, 69% will fund salaries, operational and maintenance costs. That’s a whopping Ksh 4.89 billion with only Ksh 2.15 billion left for development purposes.

From this Development budget, the Governor has no say at all on Ksh 1.097 billion because its donor funding contribution that comes with conditionalities (eg Ksh 950 million for Water and Sanitation from World Bank, Ksh 147m for Climate Change Action Plan– WB)

The balance of Ksh 1.058 billion is what is left for the Governor, in this case our H.E Wakujaa, to budget for his projects. Before he embarks on anything, he gets held hostage by MCAs who demand for their share from that balance. They manage to squeeze out Ksh 400 million as Ward Development Fund from him and split the fund into 20 million for each Ward and here brothers and sisters, the road towards having Churu Churu Projects begins.

The MCAs will split further the Ksh 20m to fund about 10 different small projects in their Wards ranging from water, ECDEs, Supply of Manure, sponsoring football tournaments, construction of toilets etc flooding us even more with the churu churu projects. Some projects may get allocated as little as Ksh 300,000.

On the executive side, the Governor is now left with only Ksh 658 million from an initial budget of Ksh 7.04 billion from which he must first spend on certain non-negotiable expenses like counterpart contribution and payment of pending bills. One of the Conditionalities given by donors is that for counties to unlock the donor funding, they must co-share in funding the projects by contributing some small amount to the project, also known as Counterpart funding.

For the Governor to unlock the donor funds for Water and Sanitation project from World Bank (Ksh 950m) he must contribute Ksh 50m. The Total amount for Counterpart funding in the draft 2023/2024 budget is Ksh 155 million (Water Ksh 50m, Water Sector Trust Fund Ksh 15m, Climate Smart Agric Ksh 40m, Red Cross water projects Ksh 5m, and Climate Change Fund Ksh 45m). Another item is Pending Bills budgeted at Ksh 150 million. That’s now Ksh 305m chopped from his balance. Amebaki na only Ksh 353 million mtu wa watu.

The story is far from over. He has budgeted to refurbish the County Assembly Chamber at Ksh 70 million, refurbish his office at Ksh 22 million and construct the county treasury at Ksh 8 million, totaling Ksh 100 million bringing his new balance to only Ksh 253m. This is what he will be left with for mwananchi projects from his executive office in Mwatate. Just imagine.

The executive has over 30 Spending Units spread across in all his 10 departments including heavy consumers like public works, roads, education, water and health departments. Each spending Unit has to be allocated something. No wonder a critical department like that for Industrialization was only allocated Ksh 300k for the whole year. And what will 300k or 500k do if not churu churu projects? Wakujaa has no choice. All factors remaining constant, it will be churu churu all the way mpaka 2027.

All the above notwithstanding, these churu churu projects have had a measure of success and impacted positively at very local levels.

For example, distances to watering points have reduced for some people where churu churu water projects were done. Social amenities like boda boda sheds, car parks, toilets, playgrounds etc have been built. Social services provision like education, health, water and rural road networks have improved. Economic projects like support to women, youth, farmers and vulnerable groups and provision of crop and animal seed materials (AI), manure, poultry, small stock like goats and expansion of commodity markets has to some large extent moved upwards the economic status of beneficiaries.

The impact of these projects cumulatively is huge but unfortunately this has not been visible to many. This is because they are small in scale and also are scattered far and wide across all the 20 wards.

Going Forward, what measures can we adopt as a county? 

First, let us throw away the budget making template currently in use. We have become captive to it and the projects contained in previous budgets spanning from local government days and we have refused to think outside that box. We keep copying, cutting, pasting and deleting here and there, patching an old cloth and calling it new. Let’s start making the budget from scratch. From problem identification to solutions.

Second, MCAs must forget the Ward Development Fund. They are abusing it for political ends and the fund has been a source of political tension in the past between the CA and CE. The funds should be pooled and projects that have greatest impact on the people be initiated. It’s a mockery to have a department like industrialization being allocated 300k and expect youth to get jobs in factories. From where now?

At the worst-case scenario, the WDF be reduced to Ksh 10m per Ward. A total of Ksh 200m would be “saved” annually amounting to Ksh 1.0 billion in 5 years. About seven years ago, the European Union Grant to us was about Ksh 115m for the Banana Factory in Taveta. How many banana factories can we do with Ksh 1 billion? Makueni County did a 200-bed capacity hospital spending Ksh 135m. How many of such hospitals can we build with Ksh 1.0 billion of money saved from MCAs?

Third, the County Executive must conceptualize flagship projects that are short term, medium term and long term and can be successively funded in more than one financial year to completion.

We must dream and see visions in equal measure. No institution develops without visionary leaders. We expect our County Executive to provide that visionary leadership. Anything short of that sisi kwisha.

Fourth, we must seek more and stronger development partners. Ksh one billion a year allocation for development will take us nowhere. It will never water our land nor grow our rich agricultural fields or unlock the trillions lying underneath our feet as minerals. The vast land that we have can be used as an incentive to bring in investors. We only need to be vigilant to keep away fraudsters.

Finally, in my opinion, the best case scenario for us is to blend a mix of churu churu projects and a number of flagship projects, a situation that enables us to reap the benefits of the diversity of such projects.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Peter Njenga

Leave a Comment

View Comments

  • Just read through na nimepata ufunuo wa mambo kadhaa ...

    It brought me back to the days when kina Hon Ngalavu Christopher Mwambingu were fighting for #WardFund even before he was a mheshimiwa ...

    I supported the idea of the Fund, with the arguement that when the funds get closer to the people at the grass roots, atleast the Common DaTuzen will get something ...

    Even when the funds are embezzled, DaTuzen will get some 'Msusure!' Little did I know that it would lead us into #ChuruChuruProjects and completely hinder #FlagShipProjects in out mighty County ...

    Am now rethinking my previous school of thought about the fund, thanks to your elaborate analysis ... 👌🏾

    How I wish corruption and fight for political mileage were eliminated in development projects ... 😤

    We will get true development, if only, we reduce politics in the projects ...

    Apparently, as it is, any development project undertaken is attached to the politician behind it and not the fund or office he or she holds ...

    Huu mradi ni wa mheshimiwa so and so, is the language out there...

    I hope the concerned have read or will read & understand, your understand thought rich write ✍️ up ...

    Mungu akubariki ndugu Peter Njenga ... 🙏🏽

Share
Published by
Peter Njenga

Recent Posts

TAITA TAVETA: SEVEN DAYS HAVE ELAPSED — HAS SENATOR KAJWANG SENT WAKUJAA’S GOVERNMENT FILES TO EACC?

  By Kwaela News Network (KNN) | Governance & Accountability The seven-day ultimatum issued to…

17 hours ago

THE ERA OF POLITICAL EUPHORIA IN TAITA TAVETA COUNTY IS OVER

  The days when political party waves and symbolism single-handedly determined election outcomes in Taita-Taveta…

1 day ago

TAITA TAVETA: CAN THE DCI CRACK THE NUT? DORCAS MLGHU’S PUBLIC OUTBURST PUTS COUNTY EXECUTIVE UNDER FRESH PRESSURE

  The growing controversy surrounding the financial management of Taita Taveta County has taken another…

2 days ago

THE GOVERNOR DISCOVERS FISCAL DISCIPLINE — FOUR YEARS TOO LATE?

  Perhaps one of the most ironic moments of Governor Andrew Mwadime's appearance before the…

3 days ago

NDARA B LAND DISPUTE: 63 RESIDENTS SERVED WITH THREE-MONTH EVICTION NOTICE FOLLOWING COURT RULING

Affected families in Mlambenyi, Golani and Mto Mwagodi face a February 2027 deadline as the…

3 days ago

THE WRONG TIME: GOVERNOR WAKUJAA’S DEFENCE

During a Senate Public Finance Committee meeting, Taita Taveta Governor Andrew Mwadime, popularly known as…

6 days ago